If you read Tristan’s actual statement, which someone posted a link to below, the reason he is suspicious is because the details are of the approach, including the specific wording used in the prompt, were non-obvious. That and the timing of when the work supposedly started circumstantially points to theft of Tristan and Levant’s work. Tristan does not actually accuse of OpenAI of theft because he doesn’t have any proof, but the sequence of events is definitely suspicious.
There is also the issue of the pressure tactics: respond to a meeting invite the same day, respond to a meeting invite on Sunday of Labor Day weekend, release your proof so that we can follow up with ours the next day. They clearly were rushing their result because they wanted to scoop anything that Anthropic may have been working on. Meanwhile, Tristan is more interested in the academic discourse, but he can no longer release the result he wanted to release, because writing good proofs takes time and OpenAI didn’t want to give him that time.