Possibly, but it definitely means he hasn't spent any significant time with it. Pay $20 and try it for a month and then post about how awful it is.
My initial experience with Claude wasn't great. In fact it completely failed at the task I gave it. But later on I began to use it in more specific ways---here's my code, can you modify it to do foo, and add a feature bar---and it really began to work for me. Was pretty incredible actually. And I began to use it to teach me and explain parts of the API to me, complete with examples based on the code I already had. And it's pretty good at helping you quickly get up to speed with code you've never seen before. Plan mode is also a key to success. I now use Claude regularly as an assistant.
Claude is also a pretty good debugging tool. Over the past couple of months I've run into problems with my code that I banged my head against for hours, knowing it was probably something simple and obvious but I couldn't see it. Finally I told Claude what was happening and had it analyze the code and more often than not it found the problem with my logic, even pointing out something in another part of the program that I hadn't considered that caused the problem.
I do very little vibe coding, but I have used Claude to add features I needed to an OBS plugin. I also used it to modify a flutter app to add complementary features to communicate with my modified OBS plugin. I have no experience in flutter or dart. But I did review the changes Claude made and they were quite reasonable.
Claude isn't perfect or all that creative, but it still is a game changer. 90% of what programmers do isn't novel or ground breaking, but just putting together existing parts in new ways that fill a need. Claude is very good at assisting in this. The only downside is Claude is fairly expensive. I can only use it for about 1 hour before I hit my 5 hour limit. And if I was to use it heavily the Pro account wouldn't last very long in a week. $100 for the max account is pretty expensive.
I'm looking at other models that are improving all the time. OpenCode cli (not too bad) with Kimi 2.5 Thinking, Qwen3. Not quite as good as Claude but still darn useful. I'm tempted to get hardware to run Qwen3 locally. Probably AMD Ryzen AI Max+ 395-based system. Seems a bit ludicrous how expensive they are for what is basically gaming laptop hardware. And I expect the price to jump in the next month, maybe even double by the end of the year.