Comment Re:Big deal (Score 1) 312
If you're so keen to convince me, why not provide a few links of your own? We can go link for link -- I'll stand you the Wikipedia link.
Here are a few on the cult issue specifically:
http://www.religioustolerance.org/falungong3.htm
http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,165166,00.html
Comment Re:Big deal (Score 1) 312
They criticise what deserves criticism and give credit where it's due. Almost all religions teach compassion, which is a good thing. Some of them have dubious metaphysical tenets or practices, which deserve criticism.
One reason for the distinction you raise is that many people regard the Buddhist metaphysic and its emphasis on individual empirical investigation as far more plausible than the Christian metaphysic and the Christian emphasis on faith.
But that's a separate issue from calling on the government to suppress something because it's a "cult", or "mind-wank". People should be free to mind-wank as much as they like, as long as they're not harming others. That's freedom of religion.
Comment Re:Big deal (Score 1) 312
Well, I guess the fascists were going to crawl out of the woodwork eventually.
From Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falun_Gong#Beliefs_and_practices):
Falun Gong aspires to enable the practitioner to ascend spiritually through moral rectitude and the practice of a set of exercises and meditation. The three central tenets of the belief are 'Truthfulness' (, Zhn), 'Compassion' (, Shàn), and 'Forbearance' (, Rn).[28] Together these principles are regarded as the fundamental nature of the cosmos, and are held to be the highest manifestation of the Tao, or Buddhist Dharma.
Truthfulness, compassion and forbearance? Holy mother of god, how horrible! We should suppress these people asap. Quick, call Cisco.
Comment Re:Cisco saw this as an opportunity (Score 1) 312
Comment Re:It's a really nice idea... but, (Score 1) 312
That's interesting... but the argument in your last sentence -- which I acknowledge doesn't represent the whole gist of your comment -- is a version of the infamous Pol Pot Defence (in which Pol Pot says "What, criticise me? What about Hitler, Stalin, Mao, and Satan? I'm not as bad as them. Go criticise them.")
If Cisco knowingly supplied equipment to suppress Falun Gong, make them pay now, not in 50 years' time. They're as good a place to start as any. Set a precedent, then carry it through to all the other bastards.
Fruit Flies Hold the Key To Faster Computing 45
Ruby Dropped In Netbeans 7 140
Comment Ahem. What the scientist didn't disclose... (Score 1) 347
Mystery of the Dying Bees Solved 347
Comment List order (Score 1) 271
Blizzard Boss Says Restrictive DRM Is a Waste of Time 563
Man-Made Atomic Clocks the Best In the Universe 267
Comment Re:Philosophy is fundamental (Score 1) 515