Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Unfortunately, Home Assistant changes very litt (Score 1) 100

If you're thinking in arrays, you're thinking too low level. Obviously the underlying code supports arrays and more advanced users can even use them in templates via the front end. The use cases for having a full GUI based abstraction of more complex data structures can probably be counted on one hand so for those cases it's easier to just let the users access via templates or custom components

Comment Re:Unfortunately, Home Assistant changes very litt (Score 1) 100

Ah that sounds similar to ESPHome or Tasmota. They have their uses, but a centralized system is needed for more complex automations.

Most users don't want to be coding to create automations. Systems like HomeAssistant (and NodeRed) have done a good job abstracting the underlying code and data to something that's more user friendly for non-developers. Most people don't even know what an array is

Comment Re:Unfortunately, Home Assistant changes very litt (Score 1) 100

Like running arbitrary IoT Apps on IoT devices?

Huh? what would be the point of that? Sounds like something the IoT device would need to support. Can look into ESPHome if that's a feature you need.

More advanced data structures have always been a little challenging to abstract for end-users. HA has a pretty good balance and of course if you want to do something more complicated you can always implement a custom component (or official one if it's something others might need).

If you can't even explain what makes your product better to someone technical, it might not be that game changer you imagine.

Comment Re:I mean - most of them are local first (Score 1) 100

Nabu Casa isn't really HA's parent company, it's a commercial service that employs the devs, but doesn't own the product. The main advantage of subscribing to Nabu Casa is remote access and tie-ins to services like Alexa and Google. HomeAssistant by itself is still run locally.

It's a shame you got a bad setup, but that's the case with computers sometimes. The good thing was that when a commercial device breaks down people just toss it, but in this case it sounds like you were able to fix it!

Comment Re:Unfortunately, Home Assistant changes very litt (Score 1) 100

Of course any devices can connect to a cloud server if you have the proper interface. I can "trivially" connect my dumb light bulb to a cloud server using a smart switch.

The point is that a zigbee device cannot connect to the internet unless the gateway is configured in a way to do so, but if you're running HomeAssistant as your zigbee coordinator then it won't do that.

Slashdot Top Deals

MS-DOS must die!

Working...