Comment Why give anyone control? (Score 2) 218
Why even CarPlay or Android Auto? Those are not the dubious features we should be scrambling to get "back". Both of those were bad choices to begin with, handing Google and Apple control of our in-car experience, sending them our location at all times to be sold to the highest bidder. I chose not them, and certainly not to let the car manufacturers get their drool-covered mitts on my experience.
I'd rather have a very good, solid phone holder I can slip my phone into and control everything myself. I have my own satnav I can trust (Osmand). My own music player over vanilla bluetooth. Nothing to tell me when and how I can interact with my device. No "I'm sorry Dave, I can't do that while I'm moving". I choose when I'm safe. Hell, when I'm waiting in a car wash lineup, I can play a movie from my VPN'ed home server. My phone holder is solid with aluminum clamp arms repurposed from a motorcycle, clamped to my Jeep's driver-side grab handle, which I don't need because I have the steering wheel. With an integrated magnetic couple charger, I am set.
Why are people so interested in handing this functionality over to their car? Or to Google? My experience is easy to interact with, feature rich, liberating, and ad and surveillance free.