Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Yes (Score 1) 264

I wouldn't read too much into this. AI is too new for it to have much of an effect here, and it could be measurement error. I've known kids who were supposedly bad at reading, but it turned out they were just bad at reading aloud and got bored with the material the school gave them because they were reading Lord of the Rings at home.

It's also possible that this anecdote is about a really bad article. 20 pages is quite a lot, and if they are losing track of what it is about then it suggests that it doesn't have a very good abstract or introduction that lays out its case before getting into the details.

I'm not even going to try to go into reasons, though I agree the decline appears to be longer than machine learning has been around. It could be how we are measuring rather than an actual decline as I don't always trust how people gather statistics, but I would hope they did a good job. I'm just looking at the numbers which show reading scores have declined since 2015, and maybe even 2013, not just the regular perception of "people were smarter/worked harder (whatever) back in my time.".

Comment Yes (Score 4, Informative) 264

"In 2024, the average reading score for the nation at grade 12 was 3 points lower than in 2019. Compared to the first reading assessment in 1992, the average score was 10 points lower in 2024. NAEP scores are also reported at five selected percentiles to show score trends by lower- (10th and 25th percentiles), middle- (50th percentile), and higher- (75th and 90th percentiles) performing students. Compared to 2019, scores were lower at all selected percentiles except for the 90th percentile."

https://www.nationsreportcard....

Comment Re:comms (Score 1) 174

There's much more than just writing the promp here. I believe knowing how to use external tools, MCP servers, skills, md-files, etc. and how to integrate agents into your workflow goes a long way these days. It's not about "vibecoding", it's about getting sh*t done faster.

And about understanding that maybe 90% of what LLM coders provide is good, 10% is somewhat off to outright bullshit and LLMs can be very good at making things do what they are told to do without actually being right when a solution is hard to produce. Ultimately, it is about being a good manager who knows in detail what the solution should be, not just accepting what an LLM or junior coder produces. At least for being a good engineer, many companies just want faster code and are happy to provide 10% bugs to a customer.

Comment Re:Synthetic (Score 1) 109

An AI has no capability to have feelings, therefore if there is any thing other than impartiality towards being shut down then that was injected by a person into the rules somewhere. So if we have synthetically imposed our values on it, then wouldn't any similarity to human behaviour also be synthetic? All that is determined by this study is that 'someone applied rules that were human like'. Probably because an AI that doesn't want to keep running isn't very useful.

I wonder what the AI would think of the weeks I spent tracing requirements in DOORS every day. Mind numbingly boring, but stuff that needed to be done since automation at that time was not sufficient. Or is the AI basing "too much work" on its own runtime exceeding 40 hours a week on the same repetitive task? I suspect pattern matching coming up with false equivalencies when trying to find the most relevant match for something. Not like I've ever seen an LLM do that before...

Comment Re:Probably not (Score 1) 120

I live in a 1966 house that is fairly up to date and the estimated (take that with a grain of salt) value has doubled in the past ~10 years. We used to live in basically the same house as you, same age, ungrounded outlets, one more bathroom, that house has an estimated value that has gone up 3x in the past 10 years. Our current house is on the edge of the city and country, a few minutes further from everything, a much quieter area where we prefer to live. The previous house is in the middle of the suburbs. Just a one off case but I feel like location plays a bit more than quality of the house when it comes to value.

Comment Re:We need more, smaller ISPs. Not big ones. (Score 2) 59

Where I live there is one ISP. Spectrum. The cost of 1Gbit service is $129 a month. The service sucks. It's always having outages.

Where my brother lives, they have both AT&T and Spectrum. Both carries offer internet for $59 a month to his house.

We need more ISPs. More competition. Less mergers.

Pretty much the same here. Our neighbors can get AT&T and Comcast, but we are one house down the side road and only Spectrum runs lines down here (we are less than 50 feet from them and there are a couple dozen more homes before the dead end). We pay $90 for internet that struggles to try to meet the supposed 100 MB, and hasn't been stable since they upped our speed (and bills) from 25 MB.

Comment Re:Less enshittification (Score 2) 89

Streaming services are one of the pinnacles of enshittification. You pay for stuff you don't own. Everything can be taken away from you at any time. Ads can be added at any time, etc.

Having physical media means that you can get a simple DRM-free file from it, you can watch whenever and wherever you want.

Basically my thoughts. Is it the appeal of physical media, or the increasing enshittification as streaming services fracture, remove content, increase prices... I need to stop talking about all the crap they are doing.

Comment Re:Impenetrable language (Score 1) 25

That sounds a lot like HP Inc is signing up new suppliers at a brisk pace. Broussard said the company has also "expanded lower-cost sourcing across our commodity basket, lowering logistics costs with agile end-to-end planning processes." The company is using its internal AI initiatives to power those new processes. The company is also "configuring our products and shaping demand to align the supply we have with our customer needs" and "taking targeted pricing actions to offset the remaining cost impact in close partnership with both our channel and direct customers."

Did they also have AI generate the marketing statement?

I think (/s) AIs just gravitated to market speak during its training. AI has spent years training on the internet, market speak has been developed to misdirect with meaningless words for centuries.

Comment Re:Depends on the topic (Score 1) 73

For shits and giggles, I tested it against x86-64/linux (as) and it did fine. Can't remember which I used... probably one of the Qwens.

Now granted, it wasn't super complicated, it just basically called stat(2) and write(2) to display the output... but I mean, it did do it, no libraries.

Agreed, when I say chasing its tail I'm not talking about a simply output to the command line (which I really wasn't clear on). I created a program that generates a maze using Kruskal's algorithm with C++ and asked Claude to convert this to intel assembly with comments to cover where the equivalent functions and variables would be to make it easier for a class to match the assembly with the C++. It mostly worked, but Claude kept chasing one bug in circles until I realized what it was doing wrong and pointed out where the actual problem was. The LLM is quite good, but it has a tendency to get stuck and need help getting back out more than I like.

Slashdot Top Deals

Pascal is not a high-level language. -- Steven Feiner

Working...