Comment Not everything is a Law & Order episode. (Score 2) 72
Whatever legal precedent is attached to a small claims court ruling is so slight as to effectively be non-existent for all practical purposes.
Companies uniformly fight all small claims cases without so much as glancing as the specifics beforehand, because the individual cases aren't worth the corporate time it'd take to come to individual go/no-go decisions on fighting each one, and not fighting small claims at all is more expensive (both in the form of the default judgements and in the form of reputation for not showing up to small claims, which attracts more people trying to make a quick couple hundred) than sending some chair-warmer middle-manager to small claims court for a day at their regular salary.