Comment "Amazing but oversold" (Score 5, Interesting) 154
If you're going to repost the entire lede of the story, at least also share the counterpoint: "Gary Marcus, a reliable critic of the field, called the release amazing but vastly oversold. Some specialists expect that once the dust settles, a few of the ten will look genuinely surprising and the rest will be classified as reachable problems that nobody had gotten around to attacking."
And ironically, or maybe unironically, this story reads like it was AI-generated. Phrases like these:
"Three objections are worth taking seriously, and the honest reading concedes all three."
"Grant every objection and the structural point survives intact. Whether the ten were cherry-picked or not, the certificates still verify. A curated result that mechanically checks is a different object from a curated result that does not."
"The cost of producing a hard answer just fell to almost nothing, and the constraint moved to proving the answer is right."
Most humans don't write quite like that.