Comment Re:hmm (Score 1) 81
The arguments are similar to "Innocent until proven guilty." Look into precepts like that; which are illogical but have cogent arguments for such policies.
It is not that hard. Racists will circumvent any simple policy or law you set because it's incredibly easy when you decide any aspect of the process. This went on 100s of years. Games with definitions and interpretations are learned by children with their parents or school's rules. They also learn that "common sense" will catch and stop them while the letter of the law is easy to game. This is why some intellectually honest judge is needed over a rigid algorithm (literal or strict constructionist bs.)
Then you have unconscious biases which people naturally do simply with natural preference towards the familiar; race has nothing to do with it - if you are uncomfortable and unfamiliar working around women you will prefer men. If you worry you'll be too tired or drunk and say what you really think and get in trouble, you'll prefer "one of your own" but even without that simply a choice between comfort level will be a factor in any "gut" decision. Hell, your music taste preferences are all familiarity. Sure these things go too far with touchy hyper sensitive people (most millennials.)
Affirmative Action was destroyed by heavy sustained propaganda so then it changed to DEI. Which is now under attack. The name will change and repeat...
The illogical position of instituting counter bias is reasonable because you can't logically counter the problem against being gamed into meaninglessness. You have to force a counter measure at least until the problem is greatly reduced. Then you can stop until it becomes a problem again. which it likely will. Could be hair color next time... except it's not stopped enough to change into something else. Not that lesser things like clothing fashion don't happen forever... but that is enough of an issue people do dress code policies and uniforms. The guilty bias is unavoidable for almost everybody but the most Vulcan of us which is why the innocent bias is formal policy.
Humans are always deluded children; except when they are actually children.