Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Submission + - The issues with facial recognition systems in the UK

Bruce66423 writes: The Guardian has three articles today on the issue

Oversight lagging behind

https://www.theguardian.com/te...

The consequences of false positives

https://www.theguardian.com/te...

UK usage by police force

https://www.theguardian.com/te...

The obvious answer is that any victim of a false positive should receive £1000 for the first event, £2000 for the second etc...

Comment Defining an electric motor bike (Score 3, Insightful) 244

What's needed is clarity about what the acceptable top speed / horsepower of ebikes should be before they are treated as motor bikes. The problem then is enforcement; the UK has such rules, but also a vast number of illegal e-bikes which are especially popular with food delivery couriers. What we don't want is a licencing regime for all bikes with electrical support, or, even worse, all push bikes requiring licencing.

Comment Or the people who refused budget requests? (Score 1) 29

If the organisation employed low quality people with no up to date experience, then those people are not really to blame. Likewise if the request for more funds was refused by the 'board', then shooting the messenger is unfair. Overall, there needs to be accountability - but of those really responsible!

Comment Great answer; thanks (Score 1) 192

I suspect that we need to think a lot harder about what school education should look like, and that probably won't conclude that the present approach is fit for purpose. One of the more interesting options is - and don't freak at its origin - the 'Accelerated Christian Education' approach, which has each kid working on their own with a computer that teaches them the ideas and then tests whether they've got it. If they're struggling they can either ask for help - and do something else until the teacher arrives - or help will arrive when the software realises that they're stuck. For kids who can learn like that, it seems to work extremely well; the term 'Accelerated' doesn't seem to be inaccurate because, as you say, the motivated / interested kid will keep pursuing what they want to pursue. Meanwhile hopefully the teacher will be able to get the strugglers up to speed.

https://www.acediagnostictest....

Comment Some things need rote learning or private study (Score 4, Insightful) 192

Multiplication tables, history dates, state and country locations on the world map, Chemical formulae including the Periodic Table, Physics equations, foreign language vocabulary and reading set texts in English. There is no virtue in learning / doing those in school time.

To a large extent however this debate is avoiding the main issue; why are we spending vastly more on education than lots of other countries and achieving far less...

Submission + - French Court imprisons French executives for enabling terrorism (facebook.com)

Bruce66423 writes: The company had made an agreement with the Islamic State group to allow the continued operation of their cement plant in Syria despite this providing financial support to IS. Two senior executives were taken from the court to prison following the verdict with sentences of five and six years.

One claimed not to have read a particularly damning email. '“I’m not a child of the internet,” he said. “Emails that I’m copied on, I don’t read, and emails from people I don’t know, I don’t open.”'

Submission + - Keep doing social science experiments? (theguardian.com) 1

Bruce66423 writes: The London Guardian reflects on the poor reproducibility of experiments in social science revealed by the latest Systematizing Confidence in Open Research and Evidence (Score) finding, which has now published three studies looking at 3,900 social science papers.

Despite the low quality revealed by these studies, it suggests that things are getting better, admits: 'Some findings don’t matter much' claims 'replication studies can themselves be flawed.... These studies should strengthen the case for change and serve as a warning. Social science is a powerful tool for understanding the world – and that trust will be built by acknowledging uncertainty, not repudiating it.'

Given the degree to which 'following the science' led to some very bad decisions during the pandemic, not least because the social impact of lockdown choices were not well evaluated, it's hard to come to a clear view. And it's worth remembering the size of the industry employed in these science studies... It's encouraging that one of its spokesmen is admitting that mistakes were made in the past. Whether this is enough reason to carry on is less clear!

Comment Laws with mission creep (Score 4, Insightful) 148

The use of the Smoot-Hawley Act to get this information is, as the defendant's argument points out, a weird use of an act with a totally different purpose. As is so often the case, the executive is seeking to get its way with legislation that wasn't intended for their purpose. It's how our freedoms die; laws nibble away at them without it being deliberate. If you can find a witch to hunt with the law, even better; the present growth of live face scanning technology in the UK is being driven by examples of sex offenders being spotted with it.

It's so much easier to rule the country if the population is kept surveiled and cowed into silence.

Submission + - EU parliament fails to renew loophole allowing tech firms to report abuse (theguardian.com)

Bruce66423 writes: 'The European parliament has blocked the extension of a law that permits big tech firms to scan for child sexual exploitation on their platforms, creating a legal gap that child safety experts say will lead to crimes going undetected.

'The law, which was a carve-out of the EU Privacy Act, was put in place in 2021 as a temporary measure allowing companies to use automated detection technologies to scan messages for harms, including child sexual abuse material (CSAM), grooming and sextortion. However, it expired on 3 April, and the EU parliament decided not to vote to extend it, amid privacy concerns from some lawmakers.

'The regulatory gap has created uncertainty for big tech companies, because while scanning for harms on their platforms is now illegal, they still remain liable to remove any illegal content hosted on their platforms under a different law, the Digital Services Act. Google, Meta, Snap and Microsoft said they would continue to voluntarily scan their platforms for CSAM, in a joint statement posted on a Google blog.'

Child abuse as the excuse for avoiding privacy protections. Who would have thought it?

Slashdot Top Deals

"Everybody is talking about the weather but nobody does anything about it." -- Mark Twain

Working...