Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 93
Well now, I made a simple statement, that retrieval of defunct satellites is a good thing, it appears that you took offense to it.
Rather, you're proposing it for a situation much different than the one you've heard of, and in that situation it ranges from impractical to pointless.
To the point of claiming I know nothing about orbital mechanics, and apparently everything I have written is simply wrong. Or off topic.
What difference does it make given it's a moot point? Besides, I didn't say that.
Of course not every example I gave was directly focused on Starlink Sats.
Back in the "what difference does it make" department. Here's what take of yours I've been arguing about this entire time:
I find it ironic that Musk is discarding StarLink Sats like garbage every day.
Do you now understand why they're discarded? And if so, why is it ironic? This isn't a problem SpaceX has any motivation to solve, but others are, and they're doing it aboard Falcons. How are they going to do it in a way that's even remotely cost effective if they're paying old space launch rates?
So relax a little before returning to the insults. Fact is, there is no physics to keep us from capture and return. There is no physics to keep us from capture and rapidly deorbiting. There are groups actively pursuing this, and clearing out dangers debris, as I have cited.
One thing that many do not understand is that collisions spew out debris well beyond the present orbit.
I don't recall insulting you. Sure, I'm being snarky, but this is exactly why: As I've already told you it's a moot point at this altitude. A more detailed explanation: A Kessler event takes place over decades. Nothing can last long enough in this orbital slot for one to occur. If, or even when it happens as some are saying it has already started, it won't have anything to do with Starlink other than the fact that the debris raining down from higher altitudes could take out Starlink.
While not a collision event, and as an example, on February 2015, a Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (DMSP) satellite of United States experienced a single breakup event induced by battery explosion, the resulting debris were so widely dispersed that extended more than 300 km above and below the pre-breakup orbit.
What altitude? Debris going "above" will come back down relatively quickly, because orbital mechanics. If you want to gain altitude, you have to increase your speed. In other words, if you're going east, you have to go east faster to go up. Like a slingshot. Likewise, a deorbit burn goes in the opposite direction to decrease altitude. If you send it upwards, it goes in an arc back downwards until it reaches equilibrium. At the altitude Starlink is at, the atmosphere is more viscous. Heavy things, like satellites, tend to resist drag better than light things, such as FOD.