Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 92

Where did you get the idea that I said anything about refueling a satellite?

It's either that or you're talking about having them do a deorbit burn, which they already do on their own, so that would make even less sense.

I'm talking about reducing space junk. I'm talking about capture and return,

/facepalm

Are ye now?

which has already been accomplished on the STS-51 mission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]. Deployed two, and captured and returned two for repair.

I don't know how much you pay attention to these things, but Starlink V3 will be in the 350km orbital shell. Nothing in that orbit will last longer than about 5 years, and smaller objects (say debris from say a collision) will fall even faster. In addition to that, Starship doesn't leave any trash behind, so you're not going to find anything like discarded boosters, discarded fairings, or anything of the sort, which is where a lot of the larger junk comes from.

On STS-49, they captured an Intelsat, attached a new upper stage on it, which allowed the Intelsat to reach it's proper orbit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org] So I guess we did capture, refuel, and return a satellite. Not what I was talking about however.

You're comparing two very different orbital shells as if they're the same. The reason it makes sense to do this in a GEO orbit is because those satellites are meant to be up there for a long, long time, and throughout their useful life they spend most of their fuel ensuring that they stay in a fixed position relative to the ground. When they're towards EOL, they move into a graveyard orbit. This was thought to be enough to prevent them from becoming a hazard, but it turns out that it's not. That is where refueling and/or de-orbiting come in.

But for LEO? Mostly a moot point, though it depends on where in LEO. Definitely not where Starlink V3 will be.

The Hubble Space Telescope has had several servicing missions.

Different bird, different orbit, waaay different purpose, cost, etc.

So there is prior art in this. While we have used vehicles like the Space Shuttle in the past, an effective and economical capture and return workflow is needed at this point. And not just for Starlink satellites.

Well that's good, because it's not needed at all for Starlink.

Speaking of non-Starlink satellites, there are other sats in higher orbits that could benefit from either capture and repair, or perhaps capture and move to an orbit that will decay rapidly. On the other side, Sats in geostationary orbit, which is some of the most valuable orbital shells, as many as 30 percent of dead sats that should be moved are not, because the way we do it now is boost them higher into to graveyard orbits. Some times that operation fails, and some real estate is lost.

There is also a strategic, intelligence value to this. As satellite retrieval ability grows, adversarial nations might give thought to capturing each other's intelligence satellites (keeping in mind that is an act of war)

Which is why way back in the past. I wrote: "And since reusability is the apparent ultimate goal, I find it ironic that Musk is discarding StarLink Sats like garbage every day. Having a satellite retrieval and refurbishing service is something I could get behind." Full quotes are always a good idea.

It's a good thing, then, that Starlink isn't doing any of this. Also, GEO is becoming a lot less useful these days. It has been ever since SpaceX proved, rather decisively, that phased array antennas with the density and size necessary are economical enough that you don't need a fixed dish anymore. Howard Hughes, Viasat, et al have lost all kinds of market share to SpaceX alone, and they probably won't be around much longer. The longer-lived cash cow for that orbit, broadcast television, is rapidly dying out to streaming services, which perform very poorly in GEO. They've only ever been used in two places: Terrestrial internet, or basically Starlink as nobody else currently offers that service to consumers. Amazon's Leo does if you happen to own an airline, which I think Delta is already wishing they hadn't done that.

That really should not be a trigger for you saying I am ignorant about orbital mechanics. Satellite retrieval, return, refurbishment, or guiding to an expedited de-orbiting in some cases, or sending a dead geostationary sat to a graveyard orbit is a extremely worthy goal, the others have already been done - and is being investigated to implement a more economical process.

There is not one thing about orbital mechanics that precludes capturing other objects in orbit.

I didn't say there was, and you still seem to be ignorant about it. There's no rhyme or reason for external de-orbiting of Starlink birds.

Comment Re: I think this amazing... (Score 1) 109

Speaking of weasel words....

Your first link quotes a couple of consultants Business Insider dug up about phased array antennas. That's a pretty small "they."

Oh boy, you're serious... Well, no, that wouldn't be weasel words. Weasel words are when you make a comment as if it has substance when it has none. I gave you direct references, and your reply is basically "nuh uh, that doesn't count because you didn't give me enough to satisfy ME!". Riiiight.... Especially the way you say they're just "a couple of consultants", which is not only false, it also adds absolutely nothing. Moreover, you obviously didn't read it:

Richard Williams, an engineer and physicist who researches and develops phased-array antennas. He noted assembling user terminals in-house would cut some costs, but not by all that much since most of the expense lies with making their microelectronic components.

"It is very, very intensive process. We're talking about people in clean rooms, and all kinds of safety protocols on top of person hours, materials, and components going into the fabrication process and machinery," Williams told Business Insider, speaking independently of his employer. "If there was a big revolution in increasing the efficiency of semiconductor fabrication for these integrated circuits, then we probably would have heard something about it by now."

There you go, somebody on the ground actually developing it, and unlike you, has actual expertise on the engineering and manufacturing side of this. You did exactly what I predicted you'd do, made worse by the fact that you did it right after I predicted that you'd do it. Just how much more of a simpleton can a person possibly get?

The second link points out that it would have been silly to make Apollo or the shuttle's drop tank reusable because the number of planned launches didn't justify it, and technology used by SpaceX wasn't available in the 60s and 70s.

Why don't you try reading further than that?

Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 92

You may be OK with this polarized news landscape, but I am not, and it's not good for public discourse. Taken to an extreme, it's the kind of thing that leads to civil wars.

If that's the case, we should be in one already. I think the internet and smartphones are probably why trust in them is so low. Namely, news moves around so fast now that they try to get the scoop and draw a narrative or conclusion around it before anybody else does, until, in some cases, it goes spectacularly wrong. This incident comes to mind:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 92

Oh, I missed this earlier:

Who is going to build the "catchers" on Mars when the fully staged, ready to be refueled Starships Land on Mars?

It's going to have landing legs for that. Like Falcon already does. The reason for catching them instead of having legs here on earth is that they contribute that much more weight, requiring either more fuel, less payload, or both. So why would you do that when you can substitute those for something you already have on the ground, such a tower already used for the launch, especially one that can be used to conveniently load and unload cargo and people instead of fishing them out of the water?

Do tell. It's so convenient how all of the internet naysayers are such experts on this topic, because then they can tell us all of the neat things they figured out all by themselves that everybody at SpaceX hasn't even thought of yet. Wouldn't you say?

Comment Re: Kessler syndrome seems inevidible (Score 1) 92

Seriously? You keep droning on about European independence and what their strategy is, (even though your version of it sounds like a terrible strategy) and you don't know anything at all about what they currently use?

I'm doubting you know anything at all about what China is doing, because what you keep saying about them is similarly dumb.

Soft landing a rocket is one thing, which China still hasn't actually done yet by the way, but there's also a pretty big gap between that, reusing it, and then making it economically viable. SpaceX had already proven that it could soft land Starship while you guys were still saying it was a failure and whining about government money going to waste, even though the government has never spent a dime on it. Oh and, have I mentioned that SpaceX has already reused two starship boosters? The economics of it had already proven to be viable without even soft catching the ship because of that fact alone, and it's already a mass production vehicle. The ship also appears to be in incredibly good shape, and has already been stress tested to tolerances well beyond what routine flights will do while simulating soft landings. Hell, ship 40 survived a dunk into the ocean that it wasn't even expected to -- the idea being that it wouldn't survive both the stress of that big heavy stainless steel hull slamming sideways into the ocean combined with thermal shock.

The only other entity to land even just a first stage booster still hasn't even proven the economics of that platform yet. But China is "really close" to you? Speak of stainless steel, China was making fun of starship, calling it a kitchen sink, saying how that wouldn't work. But now guess what? They're copying it. They've been trying to land just a booster alone for longer than starship has existed, just like Ariane.

Do you ever know anything about what you're talking about before you do so? Or you just like inventing CCP/Jihadist propaganda?

Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 92

You can't walk that one back, which I'll get to in a bit. You know what's hilarious about what you and a lot of other derps here do? You guys matter of fact make claims that I know, first hand, often witnessed with my own two eyes, are false. Usually I just roll my eyes and don't say anything, because honestly, it's pretty pathetic how just one guy you've never had anything to do with can so easily make you guys turn off your brains. You're basically the bad side of him, but without any of the redeeming qualities.

SpaceX already has FCC and ITU approval to use some Ku, Ka and E-band, that it hasn't begun using yet, and trying to do the same with V and W bands, which again, are currently unused. 500mhz of contiguous spectrum in Ku alone, that has gone untouched. The thing with those higher frequencies is that, in order to use them effectively, you need any of bigger antennas, antenna chips built to tighter tolerances, or better signal processing.

Guess what? The V3 birds have all three.

In fact, I really doubt you know anything about EM at all, and it's fucking huge. So yeah, there's plenty of it unused, but why pay to license it when you don't have any means of even using it? Womp womp.

There are other things too that I don't know first hand, but I see people like you make contradictory claims to what is already in the news, in some cases you personally comment on, only to later contradict. Another post you made recently, that I didn't care to reply to, claimed Tesla never made any affordable EVs. Actually they did, and still do.

https://electrek.co/2026/05/01...

That's from elektrek, who has an even bigger Elon hate boner than you do. But wait, there's more: The model Y in Canada meets that $35,000 psychological threshold the media kept aiming for, an entire decade of inflation after the model 3. You can't get it in the US that way though, namely because European and Canadian safety standards are low, and you need an extra $4,000 worth of parts (such as an additional airbag) to meet US standards.

I've heard conspiracy theories about Elon or the Jews coming up with mind control, but in your case it's at least partially true for both. All they have to do to fuck with your mind is...exist...and it drives you mad.

Comment Re: I think this amazing... (Score 1) 109

https://www.businessinsider.co...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/q...

If I put any actual effort into it, I could likely find half a dozen more examples. But honestly? This is kind of tiring. You guys always think you're experts on this crap, and then when it comes to hindsight, you weasel word your way into pretending you were right all along when you obviously had no fucking idea. A lot of the most prominent critics of reusable rockets have since deleted everything they've said about it from the Internet instead of saying "oh, I obviously got that wrong". The only person I'm aware who did is Neil Degrasse Tyson who now phrases his comments like "I don't think that will work, but Elon has proven me wrong before." Everybody at Ariane gets angrily (and comically) defensive about it "we made the right decision!", but if that were true, Ariane would do more than 6 flights per year right now, basically what we call a weekend in the US, instead of the ESA and everybody else in Europe sending their orbital stuff to us.

Disagree? Then tell me how you got the phased array antennas wrong. But you're not going to, instead you're going to claim that you're some kind of an expert on the topic and you already knew this would work long, long before anybody had actually done it, but you just didn't want to say anything because Elon.

Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 92

Your comment:

I find it ironic that Musk is discarding StarLink Sats like garbage every day.

Why would they stay in orbit when they're obsolete? Starship has already gone through a few generations of birds, increasing aggregate bandwidth each time.

Besides, I don't believe you understand how orbital mechanics work. You seem to be under the impression that refueling a bird in LEO orbit is just as easy or easier than GEO orbit.

Comment Re: Good (Score 1) 92

Oh you sweet summer child...this is purely wishful thinking on you part. it's definitely not limited by spectrum, and even if it was, there's plenty more spectrum nobody is using that can be used. There's still a ways to go with antennas alone (which is yet another thing only SpaceX can do right now) that can improve the use of existing spectrum while making higher frequency (and higher bandwidth) practical. In fact, for each cell, the current aggregate bandwidth is being raised by 10x what it currently is for downlink, and 22x for the uplink, just with the v3 birds alone. And that's just with using the existing spectrum with no change in modulation. The way that's being achieved is by reducing the size of each cell by roughly 91%.

These birds are also bigger and and more massive, which enables them to use an even lower orbital shell. They're basically going to be half of the altitude of where starlink started and where eutelsat and Leo currently are. It's 3/5ths the altitude of starlink's current orbital shell. That means its already good latency is going to get even better -- likely much better than what cable does, and pretty close to what fiber does, as the physical limit should be 5ms or lower.

SpaceX also has the only rocket capable of delivering these both at scale and cost effectively. Unless Ariane plans to launch one at a time or something, and on a rocket they don't even have yet, and even then it'll be a tight squeeze. Starship (the one that already landed intact) can comfortably do 40 at a time, with 60 at a time planned.

You're just full of naivete today aren't you? Or perhaps this is yet another attempt at disinformation you're already known for? Anyway, if you do your research, you can verify all of this.

Comment Re: Kessler syndrome seems inevidible (Score 1) 92

No, the point is that they don't care if it costs more. They have to have it so that they aren't reliant on anyone else, if it comes down to it. And also because they want to launch super secret stuff sometimes.

This is just as naive an argument as calling that French territory: They've already got another platform with a higher lift capacity. They're going to run into the same economic reality that caused NASA to abandon the idea.

Comment Re: I think this amazing... (Score 1) 109

Only later, do people who actually know about the subject in depth quietly point out why their insights and quick fixes are actually worthless.

They said the same thing about sub $1,000 phased array antennas and reusable rockets. NASA even has a published document explaining in detail why it would never make economic sense. Arianne literally bet against it, while publicly mocking it, and now they're trying to make a subpar and costlier copy of it. Actually I'm personally aware of many things SpaceX has done that industry experts say it either can't be done or won't ever be practical.

Comment Re: Nice! (Score 2) 109

In other words, art and artist are not one in the same.

But like many before him, there are multiple sides. One of them does a damn good job at...all sorts of things, and continues to do so. Reminds me of something Adam Savage of mythbusters said when a fanboy asked him if he heard of Nikola Tesla: "Nikola Tesla the genius, or Nikola Tesla the nutjob?"

People who want to toss him in jail or take over his companies simply because they don't like him would be cutting off the nose to spite the face. Besides, that is literally textbook fascism. Besides, we're going to need every strategic advantage we can have given the damage Pete Hegseth has already done to our military, which will likely take another generation of brass to fix.

Comment Re: Kessler syndrome seems inevidible (Score 1) 92

It's late and won't be particularly exciting, but the point has always been to ensure that the EU has independent launch capability.

Then that's a point poorly made for two reasons:

- By the time it comes in a few years, it will already be obsolete and outclassed by two others that are both proven, and have a much higher per-launch cost than the older platform it was trying to copy.

- It's not even being launched in the EU, rather it's being launched in a European/French colony. Feel free to try to argue that it's not a colony when it bears all of the hallmarks of one.

Slashdot Top Deals

OS/2 must die!

Working...