Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Can we just start over already? (Score 1) 144

How do you shut down an organization like the CIA? The mere hint of a serious attempt to tear it down would result in assassinations and the hiding of some data (critical of CIA personnel) and the backup of other data (in preparation for blackmail, etc.).

Perhaps a replacement agency could be set up, then the CIA slowly defunded with most current employees prohibited from future government employment.

Comment Re:States should use settlements to teach ad-block (Score 1) 71

Are ads the problem? My impression is that the danger of social media is the presence of people promoting violence, whether those people are loonies, nihilists, or agents of enemy governments.

Children need to be taught critical thinking, and also taught to recognize hucksters and hate-mongers.This should be a continuing part of education and does not need special funding.

Comment The Big Lie (Score 1) 188

The big lie is that everything that needs to be built is being built by big tech.

Meanwhile, we need nuclear power plants to keep up with massive growth in electricity demands.

We need desalination plants and people to dump salt in the middle of the ocean to replenish water in local ecosystems.

Those are just two obvious things.

We also need the arts, and more people reading books.

Capitalists only care about the profit in their own silo. The oligarchs are preventing more silos from being built.

That is why you tax their profits at 99% to force them to actually invest their money or pay it out to other people who can find better things to do with it than hoard it.

Comment Re:Correlation isn't causation (Score 1) 132

Cars have become ludicrously expensive so that fewer and fewer kids actually have access to them.

Irrelevant. Most of grade school education occurs before students can legally drive.

In 1970, the bottom-of-the-line American Motors car was $2,000 (A VW Beetle $1,839.) Now, a Kia K4 LX is $23,535. In 1970, the median income was $8,900, now it's $84.000. Relatively speaking, a new car is now 25% more expensive than in 1970. That's a shame, but it's a better car and it's not "ludicrously expensive."

Comment Re:Anti-immigration trying to do dog whistles (Score 1) 170

It's difficult to separate the effects of COVID from the effects of BREXIT. Since 2019, it looks as if England has done slightly worse than the EU, but very slightly better than France. BREXIT has become less popular in England.

I suspect England's problems have more to do with poor quality British politicians than the other effects of BREXIT. I watched some videos of Parliament in session in 2022 and it was comical, one person speaking to mostly empty seats.

Comment Re:For context (Score 1) 170

For an incremental improvement, change conditions so that it's in a person's self interest to work a year or 2 longer. Raise the age for getting elderly benefits. Lower taxes for people over the normal retirement age (65?), as was recently done in the U.S.. People are living longer, and having a longer healthspan. It is neither unreasonable nor unfair to encourage them work a bit longer to make their lives better.

Comment Re:The problem is jobs (Score 1) 170

The United States workforce is 170 million out of a population of roughly 330 million, over 50%. As I illustrated above, the median household income of $84,000 is more than enough to meet your criterion for a good job. Thus more than 1 in 4, not 1 in 5, have good jobs.

It is not reasonable in this context to consider children, who are 26% of the population. The figures then become 170 million out of 244 million, or 70%, thus 35%, more than 1 in 3, have "good jobs." Then figure in retirees, who are also irrelevant to the job market...

Comment Re:Not sure what to think about this (Score 1) 170

10 million is sufficient to assure genetic diversity.

******

As a point of comparison, assume everyone dies at age 80, starts working at 20, retires at 65. That's 43.75% of the population not working, or by your figuring 1.688 people working to support 3 people. Initially, that sounds like an excessive burden, but it requires a closer look.

Median household income in the U.S. is $84,000. FWIW, that includes single parent homes, and I don't know how to factor that into calculations.

In a non-nanny-state society, everybody is responsible for himself and the results of his actions. His responsibilities include supporting his children until they can support themselves. That need not be an overwhelming cost if it were not for the excessive costs of education. (For 2 children in the U.S., kindergarten + 12 years grade school + 2 years college at $20,000/year is $600,000. {Thanks, teacher's unions.} 20 years food for 2 children $100,000. Incremental rent for a larger apartment or the incremental cost for a larger house, $100,000. Other costs are usually small in comparison. That's $900,000, 2/3 of which is government-mandated education. In a free market a better education for 2 children could be provided for about $120,000, bringing the total to $320,000.)

From 65 to 80, a person should be living off what he accumulated during his working years, (In the U.S. 45 * $84,000 = $3,780,000 gross, minus expenses.) That is not living off someone else's production, that is living off the surplus created during a lifetime. A person is not being supported by someone else when he's sleeping or on holidays or weekends. All that changes in retirement is the timescale.

Taxes and support provided by government do not change the financial principles involved, that should be "money in" = "equivalent to money out." But government is inefficient, and that's a problem.

In summary: A lifetime income of $3,780,000 to support rearing 2 children for $320,000 to $900,000 leaves $2,880,000 to $3,460,000 for a couple to live from age 20 to 80. This should not be a problem or a reason not to have children. Arguing that it takes X people to keep Y people alive is pointless. Over the course of history, production becomes more efficient due to technology, meaning that it will take even fewer people to support 3 people at the same level of well-being, and that's a good thing.

Slashdot Top Deals

"There is nothing new under the sun, but there are lots of old things we don't know yet." -Ambrose Bierce

Working...