Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Love BSD, hate the article (Score 1) 45

> How articles like this leave off the big AI threats of ending the world of the effects on the environment is beyond me.

Hi there. I wrote the article. Can I help with anything?

In my personal, non-job opinion, generative AI is a scam, and the code is mostly junk. That's why we call it "bot slop".

Cloud scale LLMs are also catastrophic for the environment, yes, 100%. But they are a drop in the ocean compared to the oil industry, single-use plastics, etc.

It's bad but and it's worse because it's unnecessary, but it's not the #1 thing that is bad about it.

> I read these things and I feel like the people against AI are given a false choice.

What choice was given here?

> Like having someone asking you when you stopped beating your wife.

I don't see that there is an "or" in here. GenAI is bad. LLMs are bad. Bad for code, bad for jobs, bad for the skills and minds of their users, bad for the industry, bad for career progression, bad for writing, bad for the arts, bad for social media...

And they're also bad for the planet.

There is no "or" in there, only "and".

Comment Author says thank you! (Score 1) 45

It's been a long time since I had a story on the front page and since I've been on /. for nearly 30 years now, it's gratifying. Last time, I accidentally submitted anonymously, because I am an idiot.

Since this story was published and I submitted it, I have discovered that I made some mistakes in the article.

The statement that it's a port of the Alpine userland isn't a fair description. It's not just NetBSD's kernel, but also init and libc and more.

It's the Alpine package manager, and some other Alpine packages, but it's more like a distro of NetBSD with a better packaging tool than I described.

Once they publish an ISO you can install, I will write a follow-up piece and explain better.

Sorry!

Comment Re:AI free OS? (Score 1) 45

Article author here. You're missing the point.

> I don't think Alpine had AI before.

It didn't. That is irrelevant on 2 different points:

* This is not about AI in the OS. It is about AI-generated code in the OS.

* Alpine Linux is based on the Linux kernel. The Linux kernel is now an AI-code project. Therefore whether they like it or not, soon Alpine will contain bot slop in the kernel.

> It's a minimalist system, it often doesn't even have bloat like systemd.

True.

> AI free is here a label like "0% fat" for winegums.

No, that is wrong: you do not understand the reasons and reasoning.

No it is not. It is more like a label in clothing that says "not made with child labour". It is not about the contents. It is about the construction process.

> It's certainly true, but misleading about the competition.

It is not misleading, but you have been misled and you don't understand the motivations here.

Comment Re: Footgun... (Score 1) 45

> None of the rest - the kernel, the GUI, the file systems, device drivers, the equivalent of init/systemd, et all are from BSD derived code, they're mostly proprietary Apple/NEXT.

Hi. Article author here. What you're saying is all wrong.

Specifically:

> the kernel,

FOSS. Here's the source:

https://github.com/apple-oss-d...

*Not* BSD.

> the GUI,

True, proprietary.

> the file systems,

Some are proprietary.

> device drivers,

Only some. That is how OCLP exists.

https://github.com/dortania/Op...

I am using an OCLP Mac to type this.

> the equivalent of init/systemd,

False. It's FOSS, and here's the code:

https://github.com/apple-opens...

Launchd is the basis of NextBSD, also FOSS:

https://www.theregister.com/os...

> are from BSD derived code,

False. Mach isn't BSD. Launchd and Iokit and much of the rest of the userland are Apple or NeXT original code and not from BSD.

Conclusion: I don't think you know what you're talking about.

Comment Re:Success rate? (Score 3, Insightful) 37

The thing about ransomware is that if paying the ransom does not actually result in decrypted files no one will ever pay a ransom again.

Many of your victims won't be able to say anything even if the files aren't decrypted -- this case is a good example, since the company in question couldn't admit publicly that they were paying ransoms.

A little searching shows that scams (beyond the base "pay to decrypt") are very common. You're dealing with criminals. If you pay a ransom, they now know that you have money that you're willing to pay, and they're going to do whatever they can to get more of it.

Comment Only bug left. (Score 2) 75

Slop kiddies found the only hypervisor bug left, which I had also found a while ago, and decided to report to Sony.

And he knows this is the "only hypervisor bug left" because...he hasn't been able to find another one yet?

This smells like some dude saying "AI is better than me at my hobby, so I'm taking my ball and going home!"

Comment Re: I look forward to 2029 (Score 2) 269

Take a look at who the current frontrunners are for the next Democratic presidential nomination.

For that matter, look at what's going on during the current midterms. They've got a golden opportunity to make major gains ... and it's looking more and more like they're going to piss it all away.

Comment Re:It wasn't researchers (Score 0) 106

Ah, yes. The old "there's totally evidence to back up my statements, I just can't be bothered to give you enough details to find the evidence" routine.

The only instance that some googling shows up is the same one linked to in the summary of this story -- namely, that 404 Media worked with a "rare bookseller" (who they won't name) to put an airtag inside one of the books (which they won't name) in a shipment of 1000 books.

Comment Re:The only books they're destroying... (Score 5, Interesting) 106

I mentioned this to the other guy but yeah they were destroying rare books. A rare book seller caught them by sneaking an Apple Air tag into one of his books that he shipped to them.

There's rare and then there's "rare." From what I've seen, the people involved have declined to say what the books involved were. About the only reason I can think of to hide that is because they know that people won't be as outraged when they find out what the "rare" books actually are. However, it was a bulk lot of something like 1,000 books, so it's a pretty safe bet that they weren't exactly valuable.

The 1973 manual for a toaster that I found in my grandfather's attic is certainly rare, but we're not losing anything if Amazon feeds it to their AI machine.

Comment Re:The death of homework (Score 1) 109

AI is too easy to use, when the work is done at home. And I say, good riddance. Homework has for decades been a substitute for learning. AP classes aren't actually "advanced" they just require more homework. If AI kills all those extra hours of busywork, that's a good thing.

The historically-bad results of the final at least suggest that doing out-of-class work themselves actually helps students.

Slashdot Top Deals

"There is hopeful symbolism in the fact that flags do not wave in a vacuum." --Arthur C. Clarke

Working...