End users do not want to give up *any* control over their devices.
Your argument is irrelevant. If you want to connect to an enterprise network you are granting permission for them to control your experience. That's why BlackBerry developed BB Balance With Balance you get 2 phones in 1. Why should they have this control? Because people in general can't be trusted to always think of the company first. Multiply that fact by a few thousand and the potential for a security breach grows exponentially. It's not that they want to destroy the company (but some actually do) but they don't always understand that what they are doing may negatively impact the company.
At the end of the day there isn't anything that a fancy BES system and draconian lock down provides that we don't already have
You just told me the only thing you use the phones for is email and messaging and you don't even allow attachments. That tells me you don't know what a BES is or does.
Android and IOS just don't have really good tools to integrate with business.
I'm curious what you feel they are missing.
REALLY GOOD TOOLS TO INTEGRATE WITH BUSINESS
Everything you mention except remote wipe are for the end user. When people talk about tools to integrate with business they are usually referring to enterprise infrastructure integration tools. The problem is...The end user usually outnumbers the enterprise admin 200 to 1 so you have 200 people all going "It does what I need it to do" and 1 guy desperately trying to get anybody to listen to him about the inadequacies of the overall system. For enterprise the phone is but one piece to a very large whole. BlackBerry designed an enterprise system whereas Apple and Google designed a consumer oriented ecosystem. The former allows for fine granular control from the infrastructure to be pushed outward. The latter allows the end user to get stuff from iTunes/GooglePlay. From the very first BB phone connected to a BlackBerry Enterprise Server (BES) the infrastructure group was able to mandate policies on the device. There are third party policy tools to manage iOS devices in the enterprise but they are not as mature or feature rich as BES. Of course the new BES 10 actually has built in support for iOS/Android devices now which could aid in enterprise adoption of these platforms but BlackBerry will be making money off of each device with a seat license. But BB 10 upgrades can use existing licenses. BlackBerry wins either way.
People buy iPads because they want to run iOS.
People buy iPads because they want to runs apps. They don't even know what iOS is. The only reason they know what Android is (and by know I mean know the name Android is associated with non Apple tablets/phones that run apps that are like the apps that run on the iPad) is because Google put the name of the OS out in front.
Right before Christmas my mom calls me asking how to do something on her iPad. After trying to walk her through the steps to do what she had requested and getting nowhere fast I asked her what her iPad looked like. She said "Oh I don't know it is just a rectangle screen Samsung iPad." 0_o
She had gotten the Samsung Galaxy Tab from AT&T
Selling it as a phone that combines the security and safety of an enterprise phone with the features an fun of a "home" phone is the right approach. But they're still going to have to prove themselves on both fronts. And the clock is definitely ticking.
I don't think it's too late for them, but it's definitely the 11th hour.
iOS and Android already have this so what's going to make it stand out?
No...they don't. They really don't. Neither OS was designed with enterprise deployment in mind. The new BYOD model is exactly like herding cats. A quick glance at this chart shows just how much is left untouched.
IBM's Endpoint Manager which wants to be the BES for Apple devices is a royal PITA to use and certainly not as seamless as a BB BES solution. I am praying we ditch it for BES 10 now that it is out and allows BB, Android or iOS devices to be managed. I have been saying it since the first iOS devices started showing up...All it will take to get the entire company back on BlackBerry is for sensitive data to get leaked by one of these devices and it cost us money. Everyone will be mad because they have to give up their precious while the PR and Security teams do damage control.
We're nerds. We don't buy solutions, we create them.
There is a reason nerds have to create solutions.
Hopefully this is going to be a bit easier over time as everyones moves to LTE (does this mean that CDMA finally bites the dust?) and phones become standardized like the rest of the civilized world.
Don't bet on it.
There is already segmentation in what bands get used in different countries and of course The US carriers are deploying FDD LTE while the rest of the world leans more to TDD LTE. ClearWire being a notable exception. AT&T likes being able to charge you global roaming fees so they go out of their way to make sure you can't just hop on a European competitors network when you are in town. Here are a few good articles on just the iPhone 5 models.
Math is like love -- a simple idea but it can get complicated. -- R. Drabek