I did pay attention in high school, and college, and grad school, and I know exactly how peer reviewed science works. I've seen and read enough Peer Reviewed Publications to be able to say with certainty that 95% percent of them read as follows:
1. Define a Grand Problem, or, alternatively define a Problem and spend the first section convincing your reader that it is Grand
2. Spend about another section trying to convince the reader that your Noble Struggle Against The Unknown, as it relates to your topic, is part of the great scheme of the universe, on par with the toils of Newton, or Feynman, or Wiles
2a. Flatter your friends and colleagues who will be reviewing your paper
2b. Bash young-earth creationists, anti-vaxxers, and maybe Wall Street bankers. Not because it's relevant, but because you need be percieved as a little left-of-center in order to avoid inviting silly nit-picks from your reviewers.
3. Recycle some figures from old lecture notes or homeworks (depends on who's the lead author) and some equations that kinda relate to them that you finally got around to typesetting after they've spent a good year on the back of an old envelope or a post-it note
4. If so inclined, spend a section making wild-ass claims and extrapolations about how something you typed up in the wee hours of the morning before the submission deadline is ground-breaking and earth-shattering, and the ignorant masses should be grateful that you deigned to solve their problems for them
5. Pointedly thank your sponsor in a way that implies you want more money, and the world depends on you getting more money
6. Cite a whole bunch of past publications, possibly your own, which relate to your topic in any way more than none.
The good papers on the other hand, tend not to make wild-ass claims and extrapolations, and at worst only suggest possibly unfruitful avenues of further investigation, and above all, do not give you a plot of 150 years' worth of noise and with a straight face tell you that there is absolutely no uncertainty in future predictions.