Compare CheckMark Payroll vs. Payroller

CheckMark Payroll Software is a desktop-based payroll management solution designed for small businesses, accountants, bookkeepers, and payroll administrators. Available for Windows and Mac, it helps simplify employee payments, wage calculations, deductions, and payroll tax reporting. The software supports hourly and salaried employees, overtime, bonuses, commissions, and multiple pay rates. Users can configure pay schedules, manage earnings and deductions, and track paid time off (PTO). With support for unlimited employees and payroll runs, it offers flexibility for businesses with varying payroll requirements. CheckMark Payroll Software includes tools for printing payroll checks, generating ACH direct deposit files for submission to banks, and preparing US payroll tax forms. Supported forms include W-2, W-3, 940, 941, 943, and 944. Electronic filing is available for supported forms, subject to applicable requirements. For reporting and financial oversight, the software provides more than 40 payroll reports, along with department and job cost tracking. These features help users review payroll expenses, analyze compensation, and maintain organized employee payroll records. Integration with supported accounting applications can further simplify financial recordkeeping. As a desktop solution, CheckMark Payroll Software is suitable for organizations that prefer dedicated software for managing payroll rather than relying entirely on cloud-based services. Its combination of payroll processing, payment tools, reporting, and tax documentation helps reduce repetitive administrative tasks & maintain consistent payroll workflows. CheckMark Payroll Software is a simple and affordable option for small businesses, accounting firms, bookkeepers, & payroll professionals.

Payroller offers a comprehensive solution for generating Single Touch Payroll reports all within a single application. You won’t need any accounting expertise, expensive consultations, or complicated systems to remain compliant. This platform also allows you to effortlessly manage employee assignments without the additional expense of a separate rostering application. With integrated GPS tracking, you can be confident that your team is where they need to be, ready to work without incurring extra charges. You can invite your tax accountant to join Payroller, granting them access to your financial data and alleviating your tax-related responsibilities, eliminating the hassle of exporting and emailing documents. Every business with at least one employee is required to report salary, PAYG, and Super information to the ATO, leading to the implementation of Single Touch Payroll (STP). You can create rosters and assign shifts easily, while employees can clock in and out and complete their timesheets through the Employee app. Additionally, you can quickly approve timesheets, ensuring they are included in your upcoming pay cycle. This streamlined process not only saves you time but also enhances overall efficiency in payroll management.