Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook


Forgot your password?

Journal Planesdragon's Journal: 3 Political Axis 4

After discussing things with Chacham, it occurs to me that we have not two, but three political axis in this country.

Right Wing vs. Left Wing: This is the major arc, one that I have previously described as "Righteousness over Liberty vs. Liberty over Righteousness."

Liberal vs. Conservative: This is a minor arc, but one that gets misused very often. The proper use, by the actual meaning of the words, would be "against the status quo vs. for the status quo."

Optimist vs. Pessimist: This is the least spoken and most important arc, and there are likely better terms for it. Some politicans believe that people are fundamentally good, and that the rest of us just need to get out of the way and keep wickedness at bay. Others hold that people are fundamentally evil, and need to be taught and restrained lest they bring ruin to us all.

Republican advocates (by which I mean, pundits) have sucessfully maligned the liberal/conservative arc as new names for left wing vs. right wing. This deprives us of needed vocabulary, and leaves the words "Judge Roberts is a Conservative Right-winger" as meaning the opposite of what they really mean--someone who values righteousness over liberty but will not change the status quo.

And this isn't something that only damages the left, either. George W. Bush should have ran as a "Liberal Republican", willing to change the way the system works for the better. He did, in fact, run on that idea both times, he just didn't admit it.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

3 Political Axis

Comments Filter:
  • Since Optimist/Pessimist seems to cover the religious spectrum quite nicely- it seems, oddly enough, that the more religious I am, the more pessimistic I become- largely because of the huge disconnect between ideals and reality in this country.
  • by Chacham ( 981 ) *
    Why not rename them then to

    1) Thinking/Values []
    2) Change: Proponent/Resistor
    3) Mentor/Advocate []

    The funny thing is, 1) is T/F, 2) is I/E, and 3) is P/J. If you could make a S/N difference you can have the MBTI all over again. :)

    I do resist change, prefer thinking, and am a teacher (though i do not like to coerce, so practically i am a advocate), its works well, making me IxTJ.
    • by Timex ( 11710 )
      The last time I took an MBTI test, I came out as ENTJ. Not entirely sure how that would carry over to the newly-renamed socio-political groups, though.
      • by Chacham ( 981 ) *
        Would be interesting to venture guess though. For if type does affect political affiliation, with the individual letters meaning different views, the interaction between them and which the person consider more important would be rather interesting, or at least amusing.

Nondeterminism means never having to say you are wrong.