Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!


Forgot your password?

Slashdot videos: Now with more Slashdot!

  • View

  • Discuss

  • Share

We've improved Slashdot's video section; now you can view our video interviews, product close-ups and site visits with all the usual Slashdot options to comment, share, etc. No more walled garden! It's a work in progress -- we hope you'll check it out (Learn more about the recent updates).


Comment: Kuhn and paradigms (Score 1) 575

by truckaxle (#30220884) Attached to: New Theory of Gravity Decouples Space & Time

It sounds like you're claiming that Kuhn didn't believe that a new paradigm offers more accurate results than the last, which he almost certainly didn't.

If he said something controversial along those lines, he might have meant that our perceptions don't actually reflect reality as it really is, so as we are trying to mold science into our reality, we aren't necessarily molding it into a model of actual reality.

Sokal may have been correct that Kuhn didn't make the distinction, but that doesn't mean Kuhn didn't have a valid concern that our scientific reality is socially-constructed. Again, I don't know if Kuhn actually believed this, I'm just guessing based on my reading of Kuhn that he wouldn't have said something as controversial as what you've implied.

Kuhn did not deny that sciences progresses, however he did subtlety deny that we are progressing toward anything - such as closer approximations to the truth or objective reality.

Read Weinberg criticisms here


Comment: Re:Not again (Score 1) 575

by truckaxle (#30219568) Attached to: New Theory of Gravity Decouples Space & Time

From what i know of Thomas Kuhn he believed that science is social construct and that the new paradigms don't fit reality any better than the last. To which is think is a load.

As Alan Sokal pointed out in his recent book the discovery aspect of science is a social construct but the justification part is not and this distinction is where Kuhn missed the boat.

Comment: Re:It's unclear why this is a bad thing (Score 1) 1164

by truckaxle (#29011979) Attached to: College Credits For Trolling the Web?

Why are clam fossils at the top of very young mountains?

Because the earth is very old, continent uplift and subsequent erosion.

ID addresses such an issue?

BTW some ignorant and misinformed floodist think sea shells on top of mountains is evidence of a flood - sorry to say it actually falsifies a flood. Take for example the Grand Canyon, on the Kiabab plateau, there are sea shell fossil that sit on top a geological column that contains fossilized foot prints, rain drops, ripple marks, mud cracks, etc. So just how did these dense organisms find their way to the top?

  I think you deserve D- for not showing any work and confusing YEC with ID.

Comment: Social, curious and empathetic (Score 1) 774

by truckaxle (#26698893) Attached to: New Paper Offers Additional Reasoning for Fermi's Paradox

As a species we're violent, irrational, deluded, greedy and self interested.

The occasional deviations from this norm in no way redeem us.

If I had a choice not to be involved with this disgusting species then I wouldn't either.

We are the product of evolutionary forces, while we may be violent, irrational, deluded, greedy and self interested we are also social, curious and empathetic.

I would suspect that any other life form that is a product of the same evolutionary forces would share a similar mix of these attributes.

Comment: Re:Rational (Score 4, Insightful) 807

by truckaxle (#26625991) Attached to: Marijuana Could Prevent Alzheimer's, New Study

I'm of the opinion that all driving while intoxicated laws are inappropriate. Either you're driving recklessly or not. If you are, go to jail. If not, go home and sleep it off.

Really! Sometimes the indication that someone is driving recklessly is when they plow into the side of a car, killing and maiming the occupants.

Drunk driving laws and enforcement do save lives and prevent many needless tragedies as they statistically highlight those that are most likely to be involved in an accident - they should be tougher if anything.

It is not best to swap horses while crossing the river. -- Abraham Lincoln