OK...so what if a Hezbollah studio "can make as good a Marvel movie as troop of thespians, team of writers, camera operators and directorial staff, VFX studio and associated staff, all while doing it cheaper and faster, why not?"...would you let them?
Of course I would let them, how could I even stop them? Now would I buy such a film and show it in my theater chain, probably not but maybe some operators in Jordan and Syria would..
The entire history of entertainment? Really? There were a lot of Everyman plays. You bet the troop in the next town just "stole" it and did their own.. You are the one trying to apply a lens of what is actually very recent history here.
Yes someone should absolutely be allowed to generate and sell Superman Porn, the character is what ~85 ears old now! Why on earth should DC still be allowed to milk it, not a single persons who worked on the original character is still drawing a salary there, if any are even alive.
but this is a business....people shitting out this generative AI slop want to monetize their lazy efforts built on the name recognition of companies that spent over 50 years building up IP and lore. It's illegal for good reason...not your irrelevant nepo-baby rant, but because no...it's fucking hard work making a good story and character...I suggest you try it and see how hard it is...any idea you have in your head? 90% chance it's just some other story you heard from another writer...OK, you have an original idea?...taking a cool idea into a decent script?...really fucking hard....nearly every bad movie ever made started with a cool idea and got ruined by a bad script. Lots of extremely talented individual shit out horrible work. A great example?...Avatar...James Cameron is as talented as they get and Avatar 2 is boring AF....really high quality from talented people, but no one cares!!!!...same with Ridley Scott's Prometheus movies. M.
Exactly its business. The product is what is valuable. The buyer does not care at all what your production costs are, only if he can get something competitive elsewhere. Competitive might even be an inferior but cheaper substitute. If someone can make money with AI slop they should, if they can make money with really good AI products - even better. It is illegal until someone decides the change the law gets changed. There is enough money in play the law absolutely will get changed, get over it.
Writing stories is hard because it takes a lot of effort, people used to pay wild someones of money for large textile products too, than progressively more automated looms were invented. We don't only get sloppy low quality blankets and rugs, I can go to Walmart get something nicer than my Great grand parents could have for the cost of several months salary! Sure there is also a lot of junk, but that is choice! Sometimes you just want slop because new kitten will probably pee on it. Same thing with film, sometimes you just want to crappy movie to unwind with in your motel room, you'll fall asleep before it is over anyway, it might even be better if it is slop! On the other hand lots more creators can see their ideas thru to full production without the enormous investment risk.
I don't hate the industry, but I don't love it standing in the way of progress, at the expense of everyone else. While the same people who demand protection for their work, would turn around and destroy the livelihood of some commerical driver by importing 1000s of illegals and handing license to "no name given' and pretend to be virtuous. The world changes the entertainment industry needs to "fucking deal.."