Comment: Re:10 Year plan vs daily/weekly bullshit laws (Score 1) 270
Thank you!
It is so nice to see a post from someone who lives in the real world. So many among the slashdot community suffer from ideological inebriation, if not outright delusional thinking. What the hell do techies know about politics, war, economics or anything for that matter? About as much as anyone else who isn't an expert in those fields.
It is very easy to take an intractable and unsolvable problem, of which our world offers up many examples, and standing at a distance from the problem, oversimplify it in order to come up with a supposed solution that would do nothing to address the issue, and would often create far larger problems if ever implemented. Leftists and Social Conservatives are both infamous for this.
Life is hard, but it is harder when you are stupid, and the irony is that intelligence makes one capable of greater levels of stupidity because such a person can rationalize unworkable ideas that a less intelligent person would give up on, especially when that person lacks the direct experience that would serve to disabuse them of their fantasies.
Or as George Orwell once said, "Some ideas are so stupid only an intellectual could believe them."
Without experience and feet-on-the-ground interaction and grappling with the problem at hand, even the most intellectually advanced notions about the nature of the problem and its solutions are nothing more than daydreams.
Adam Smith described people like Comsky as "wise in their conceit." The fact that a person is profoundly talented and knowledgeable in one area says nothing about their talents or understanding of unrelated fields. As Richard Feynman put it: "I believe that a scientist looking at nonscientific problems is just as dumb as the next guy.” An artist looking at non-artistic problems is just as dumb. A writer looking at non-verbal problems is also just as dumb. Competence and skill are not generalize-able, but specific. Bobby Fischer was one of the greatest chess players of all time, but his general life skills were totally lacking.