Comment Re:what google has to say about it (Score 1) 96
No it is not scientific.
Science is about facts, not policies. Ideally, policies are decided based on these facts, but at that point, it stops becoming science and it becomes politics.
A scientist's job is not to support a politician over another, decide on budgets, or anything like that. What a scientist can do however is point out the possible consequences of a policy, backed with data and using proper methodology. He can make recommendations on what to do to achieve a certain goal, referencing relevant scientific results, but not decide what to do with these. Scientists don't oppose, they falsify, it means they can point out lies and other statements that don't align with facts, but by itself, a political decision is not something that can be falsified even if the context can be.
Now, scientists are also people, they can engage in politics, have opinions, and of course, they need to pay their bills. But here, we are talking about scientists as people, not science as an activity. Politics about science is not science.