"Many open-source software projects have a BDFL, typically one of the project founders. In a healthy project, that authority is nearly exclusively moral authority. There is little or no real legal or contractual authority resting with the title holder. Moral authority is important. It allows the BDFL to resolve disputes, and a healthy project needs one or more persons with that kind of authority. What’s vital is that the authority can be challenged, and, if not exercised on behalf of the community, lost. The fact that moral authority can be lost is the best insurance it will be well-used.
You might want to look into allodial title then.
Your argument is like saying that because the Federal Government built the roads and highways upon which I drive my car, anyone in the country should be allowed to use my car any time they want. And that is completely absurd.
Yes, it is absurd, as strawman arguments tend to be.
It would be more like my saying that anyone benefiting from the highway system ought to revere free speech and the other principles upheld by that sponsoring government.
The reason the analogy is most clumsy, though, is that the highway system isn't exactly a communications mechanism.
It would more like your running a phone server and having a say over what exact words are used by the people conversing on it.
I'm not arguing against your property rights. If you want to bar people's access to your property, you have that power. You should not, however, feel empowered to audit their very words. Those do not belong to you, and they are manifest as a feature of opening the site to the outside world.
God gives us all rights, and we still have all of those not specifically restricted by democratic process. You, for example, have the right to enjoy sex with your adult sister. Having the right, however, doesn't make it a morally correct choice automatically.
It’s a simple solution, that some of my friends also do: The evening before going out, we eat a piece of good quality red meat. A filet steak preferably. That’s it. No hangover. No headache. Nothing.
We’re doing this for years.
To the systems programmer, users and applications serve only to provide a test load.