Comment Re:Not the best summary... (Score 1) 195
No, it's not the same problem at all. *No* vaccine is perfect, whether it's because the pathogen mutates slightly, or because the immune system doesn't learn that the (harmless) pathogen in the vaccine was harmful. The way vaccines work isn't perfect immunity, but herd immunity. They work well enough to prevent outbreaks, which is a public health concern, and if you're one of the lucky ones for whom the vaccine worked, then you're better off too. Unfortunately, there's no way to know, beforehand, whether your individual vaccination will work without deliberately exposing you to the pathogen, which is both unethical, and an unnecessary risk.
Some pathogens mutate quickly, like the flu, so vaccines are only good for a very limited time. We know this. But they will mutate with or without a vaccinated population, so it doesn't make sense not to vaccinate just because it won't be perfect.
Antibiotic resistance is a problem, but again perfect use of antibiotics is only a mitigating factor for resistance, not a panacea, because no antibiotic is perfect either. At some point we will need to find either new antibiotics, or alternative treatments. It's actually much easier to develop new vaccines than to find new antibiotics.