Comment Re:bad info (Score 2) 257
The Scouring of the Shire was actually one of my favourite parts of Return of the King. The final battle felt really overstretched, like Tolkien was having trouble keeping track of his characters by that point, and it was good to return to a more well constructed chapter.
It also resolves the character arcs for Saruman and Wormtongue - something the movie (even the extended edition) failed to do.
I would definitely have been happier to see that as the finale rather than twenty minutes of 'everyone gets old and gets on a boat'.