Comment Re:You know it after you have seen it. (Score 1) 446
In my experience, students in general are the worst judges of teachers.
We have to ask ourselves what the purpose of education is before we can judge teachers. If we step back and decide that the purpose of education is to maximize success, then I would conclude that the best judges of teachers are, quite simply, successful people!
If you polled all of the most successful people about which teachers led the most to their success, I suspect that the vast majority of them would point to the teachers that truly challenged them - the teachers that made them work relentlessly to solve problems on their own, or those who would not reward anything less than perfection. These teachers are likely to score the lowest in the student rankings, because when you demand top results, many students are not going to be able to deliver.
Of course, very few of us actually end up being truly successful, so the system reflects reality. So, how about we allow the teachers to teach toward the top of the class - or heaven forbid, the median - and be happy knowing that teachers are challenging our students to the best of their ability. Then we can judge them years later by how many of their students go on to be successful.
What's that you say? What about the other kids? The ones at the bottom who couldn't cut it? Well, that's no different than things are now. Only right now if kids don't cut it, the school gets shut down and replaced by a charter school that can selectively reject all those 'underperforming' kids from attending...