Comment Re:Interesting (Score 2) 111
I haven't seen "A for Andromeda", so I'll take you at your word, and comment on the series, since I think the premise is utterly absurd.
The idea that an extraterrestrial civilization would send out a "tough love" kind of virus, in order to teach us a lesson in cooperation, is incredibly naive. Firstly: if contact with an alien civilization is made, it's likely to be accidentally picking up a private signal on our part, and we'll probably NEVER understand the signal in itself. It's overwhelmingly probable that it would have totally indecipherable content, no matter that we could figure out that the signal is not from natural emission.
Secondly: Why the hell would another civilization, with superior technology to us want to help us at all? We're essentially shaved apes with thermonuclear weapons! We aren't much smarter than the animals we dominate. Our only real advantage over other animals is our ability to communicate through complex language, and even then we really suck at it. We can't agree on most things, and those of us who do seem to only be like minded due to meme viruses that pretty much break the useful parts of our minds regarding making advances to the human race (religion anyone?)
Thirdly: What do we have to contribute to a galactic society that they can't just take from observing our broadcasts? We pretty much have nothing to offer. We're insanely optimistic. In fact, we have to be irrationally optimistic in order to not be labeled severely depressed. Depressed people see the out of control nature of the universe and what happens to them, and realize that any event they do have control over are insignificant to the universe and 99.9999% of the people on earth, so they despair at the knowledge of their own impotence. This is logical, but bad for mental health. How fucked up are we that we need to think that we matter in order to keep from killing ourselves.
In all it's a crazy idea that any extraterrestrial civilization would ever want to contact us, much less carry us along, other than for pure altruism. And from all the study I've done of humans, the correlation between size of a society and altruism has a negative correlation as a society grows.
Just a few thoughts about the above description of "A for Andromeda". I'm going to look for it now and see if I'm just a bloviating dick.