Comment Re:That is why you use your own router (Score 1) 253
* I see no reason to let Comcast profit additionally unless I get something in return like extra bandwidth or a discount on my bill.
Like access to wifi when you are away from home?
* The neighbor isn't paying for any any service calls that get made should the equipment fail.
This doesn't change anything.
* The neighbor may be involved in illegal activities I want no part of given that law enforcement is going to come to me first if there is a problem.
Why would you suspect that? Perhaps you should buy the house next to you, so that the feds don't step on your lawn as they bust down his door.
* There is a non-zero probability that the neighbor's use of spectrum may interfere with my use of that spectrum and I'd rather not facilitate that.
Yes, the alternative is that comcast lease space from the electric company and set up their own wifi hotspots on every pole. That will be much better for your spectrum as it degrades your signal at all times instead. Sounds like a better plan.
* It offends me that Comcast could provide extra bandwidth to me for close to zero marginal cost but instead chooses to charge me for it.
Are you suggesting that bandwidth capacity is free? Naive.
* I don't really care to give people any reason to hang around closer to my home than necessary
Don't worry, I don't think anyone wants to be closer to you than they need to be.
* It's unclear if my bandwidth is protected and given priority access (my guess is that it is not)
You appear to guess wrong a lot.
* Comcast charges absurd rental rates for their equipment so I should get full access to the capabilities of the equipment if I'm renting
Then buy your own.