Comment ChromeOS Lightbar support should not be in kernel (Score 1) 232
For all the noise about systemd, we are totally ignoring the fact that it's the Linux kernel that is the most egregious violation of UNIX modular philosophy. ChromeOS Lightbar has no place in main kernel distribution. System should at least provide enough of a stable binary interface for users to get a binary from outside developer and use it for a couple years. It's not crazy for a non-critical driver like this run in userspace, where a crash is less likely to bring down the whole system.
Anyone interested in learning system programming, or getting their pet gadget to work with Linux, should be able to maintain the project without having to convince Linus Torvalds to take it on or make monthly patches to accommodate ever changing kernel interface. For that matter, someone should be able to write a new kernel and have it work with a decent subset of Linux drivers. In the meantime, core Linux maintainers can focus on fundamental projects like kdbus rather than making LED lights on one particular laptop blink.