Comment Re:This again? (Score 1) 480
Consider, for example, the momentum from a photon. We can clearly generate photons through, say, an LED, emit them, and increase momentum of one object without a violation of the conservation of momentum. The thing is that we don't think that energy has momentum
Of course energy has momentum. Photons, in particular, have momentum. That's why there's nothing strange about the experiment as you describe it - you increase the momentum of your rocket, but that increase is exactly counterbalanced by the momentum of the emitted photon. And when that photon hits something eventually, it will transmit its momentum to that thing etc. Overall, momentum is conserved, not just "right now", but at any future point. This doesn't seem to be the case with this engine.