There should be plenty of ways to deal with hosted content on someone's server without resorting to breaking core functionality of Internet services like DNS!
Unfortunately, to the asshole lawyers these companies employ ... the core functionality of the internet be damned.
They simply don't care about anything but their own profits. They just want to be in charge of how all technology is used.
"A takedown notice program, therefore, could threaten ISPs with potential secondary liability in the event that they do not cease connecting users to known infringing material through their own DNS servers,"
What they want is pretty much the nuclear option. Because they say so, something needs to be removed from the internet, and anybody who doesn't gets squashed like a bug.
Who gives a crap about analogies? The MPAA have one goal here: to make every piece of digital technology on the planet be only usable in ways defined and approved by them.
Fuck that. Having media companies in charge of this crap is a terrible idea.
This is why ISPs need to be classed as a common carrier .. what happens on their network is none of their business, and they don't have liability for it. This takes away the bullshit ability of corporations like Sony from being able to dictate how technology is used.
This whole notion of secondary liability is crap.
But for any Anonymous hackers out there, maybe all executives at the MPAA or any of their law firms ... they now have secondary liability for being douchebags and assholes, and have forfeited their right to privacy.
This is just corporate control of way too many aspects of the internet. So fuck Sony and the other guys in the MPAA. I sincerely hope they all get this treatment.
The idiotic DMCA was a terribly written piece of legislation which put far too much power in the hands of multinational corporations. And idiot governments around the world have been entrenching it in law.
At this point, I think Sony has more rights than I do.
So to hell with them. I say start punishing them, and cause as much economic damage to them as can be done.
The goals of the MPAA et al do not coincide with the goals of the rest of society. And they shouldn't be having their business model entrenched in law. They're just a bunch of parasites who feel entitled to revenue.