So the best solution is to have neither?
No. The best solution, as I have stated, is to have the books needed to pass the standardized tests.
Look, Apple is offering to donate iPads. They are NOT offering to donate chemistry textbooks.
And that is the problem. By donating the iPads, Apple gets a tax write-off and the schools end up with broken/stolen tech that ate up resources.
a. Apple could pay their taxes and the government could use that money to buy those books.
b. Apple could donate those books INSTEAD of the iPads.
c. Apple could donate a portion of the proceeds of selling those iPads.
Why isn't Apple working on getting the books that would cost a lot LESS than those iPads? Because Apple is looking out for Apple. And using those kids as PR.
To say that "nothing" is better, because the iPads will just get stolen anyway, is just a cynical rationalization by people that want to feel smug and superior, criticizing these donors, while doing absolutely nothing themselves.
I've just given you three scenarios that would be better.
You are the one claiming that Apple's only option is to donate iPads.