Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Wrong channel (Score 1) 667

They should ask the Commedy Channel. They would be great between Family Guy and Tosh.0

Already been done as it happens: Family Guy had a clip from an 'edited' version of Cosmos in which the Earth was explained to be 'hundreds and hundreds of years old'.

IIRC, the "hundreds and hundreds" was an obvious and sloppy voice-over (of the original "billions and billions") to drive home the fact that it was edited.

Comment Re:Whatabout we demand equal time of our views ins (Score 1) 667

75% of people in the USA think the bible is the word of god, or inspired by god.

Well, hold on. "The word of God" and "inspired by God" mean two very different things, the former being "fundie" and the latter decidedly not. I think it's important to keep that in mind when considering the 75% statistic. And I'd be curious to know how it splits on the "word" vs. "inspired" opinion, especially how it splits geographically.

It appears that most theologians are using rational, post enlightenment ideals, to cherry pick the good parts from the bible, and explaining away the parts that are evil, or contradicted by science as metaphor.

And that's definitely a Good Thing (TM). I don't recall the theologian who said this, but the Bible is not a book, it's a library.

Once you start down this path you are pretty close not needing the bible at all for your moral outlook, and discarding the iron age myths in favour of modern secular morals will seem a sensible step.

Fair enough. But I don't think anyone would disagree that our modern secular humanistic moralities have been at least shaped in part by the bible and other religious texts.

Comment Re: Sigh. (Score 1) 227

Newton said the instant the Sun were to just go away the planets would continue in the direction they were headed at the time,

More to the point, Newton's law of gravity assumed that gravity acted instantaneously across space.

Einstein first theory of gravity didn't do that as light takes 8 minutes to reach the Earth. 10 years later Einstein refined his theory saying gravity acts at exactly at the speed of light, which satisfied Newton's laws.

Einstein didn't have a "first" theory of gravity. His 1905 paper on special relativity had nothing to do with gravity, but it did postulate that no physical effect (including gravity) can propagate faster than light. Ten years later, he finished his general theory, which was indeed about gravity.

In Einstein's general theory, gravity acts at the speed of light, but that doesn't "satisfy" Newton's assumption of instantaneous action. Einstein's general theory does approach Newton's law for the case of smaller masses and shorter distances. And Newton's law can be "patched" to accommodate the speed-of-light propagation of gravity, but not the other effects in Einstein's general theory, such as large-mass corrections, space-time effects, bending of light by gravity, and so on.

cite: PBS The Elegant Universe - Einsteins Dream

I think you might want to watch the show again. BTW, this thread is about radio waves not gravity.

Comment Re: Sigh. (Score 5, Informative) 227

Radio transmissions do not occur at the speed of light.

Radio waves and light waves are both electromagnetic radiation, just at different wavelengths. In vacuum, electromagnetic radiation travels at speed c for all wavelengths. In non-vacuum media, there may be some dispersive effects that cause the speed to change with wavelength, but those effects are very small in air.

In short, radio waves travel at the speed of light because, in a very real sense, radio waves are light, just not light at a wavelength our eyes can see.

Comment Re: Ridiculous. (Score 1) 914

Tests have already been done on countless millions of people. None of them complained about being dead, said they'd rather be doing something else, or petitioned to be made no-longer dead. Zero.

I work in Technical Support. I can tell you we get dead people calling in on an hourly basis.

Whoa, Saint Peter just posted as AC!

But an hourly basis? Down here on Earth, about 6K to 7K people die every hour. You must be taking that time-dilation drug in Heaven.

Comment Re:Ridiculous. (Score 1) 914

IIRC from the DS9 episode, O'Brien experienced a simulated sentence but actually spent very little time in prison. In this way, he was "punished" but without taking away a great deal of time from his life.

And that makes me wonder: rather than use this drug to make 30-year sentences seem to last 1000 years, why not use it to make shorter sentences seem like they last 30 years? Setting aside the important issue of how long it takes to rehabilitate someone, there might be a case for an incarceration that takes up less of a person's lifetime and fewer resources of the correction system.

Comment Re:Being forced to submit... (Score 1) 529

Funny, really, how people can find it comforting to believe a book that tells them that, out of the billions of people on the planet, a mere 144k of them get into heaven.

Only the Jehovah's Witnesses say that.

Strictly speaking, it's 144,000 chaste male Jews. Jehovah's Witnesses are gentiles. (Some are married and female. Strike three for them.)

The problem, as usual, is people reading the bible literally. Revelations (like Genesis) is an allegorical story intended to convey a philosophical idea. Interpreting it literally is just crazy, but of course, people do it anyway.

Comment Re:Proof that Karl Marx was right (Score 1) 529

A more complete version of the Marx quote (from the same Wiki source):

Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.

I think it's important to include the extra context when citing this famous quote from Marx.

Slashdot Top Deals

When it is incorrect, it is, at least *authoritatively* incorrect. -- Hitchiker's Guide To The Galaxy

Working...