Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
User Journal

Journal Grrr's Journal: Karma be darned 2

(shrug)

Moderation seems to be much less reliable than before - and /. karma remains puzzling. Being considered 'Excellent' doesn't mean one is trusted to moderate. (Whether or not my own moderation was valuable is not the immediate point. It seems to me that someone whose value to the community is downgraded should be informed of that by a change of adjective, and not being allowed to moderate implies that one's metamoderation is not to be valued either...)

Anyway, I'm going to continue declining the karma bonus when I postanymore. Qué sera.

In the unlikely event you want to see more interesting writing from me, try fal.net or grrr.net .

<grrr />

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Karma be darned

Comments Filter:
  • I haven't had mod points in so long, I can't remember when I last had them yet my karma is rated as Excellent.

    I read somewhere that the moderating system is such that if you're too active, they won't give you points. Which of course makes no sense since one would think that an active person would be the one you want to moderate people.

    Also, I don't know if the meta-moderation affects ones ability to get points but it should. Get too many Unfair ratings and the chance of you getting points should decline.

    I
    • I haven't had mod points in so long, I can't remember when I last had them yet my karma is rated as Excellent.

      Never having had the ability to moderate, I can't realistically sympathize, but I've been hoping my efforts at meta-moderation might yield some fruit. Right now, I don't really see how it works and I'm pretty sure I've cultivated a following of "anti-moderators" who delight in slapping me with a "Troll" or "Overrated" tag just to be contrary.

      Nobody ever said it would be fair. I think when you

All seems condemned in the long run to approximate a state akin to Gaussian noise. -- James Martin

Working...