Not at all. I would rather have an Android phone. But Tmobile's coverage is worse than AT&T in this area.

I've actually looked into buying a Rodgers branded g1 android phone (from Canada). That phone will work with AT&T 3G here, but its an Android phone. But that requires a big outlay of cash to get the phone (though I may make it back from selling the iPhone).

I had Verizon for near 10 years. However, this last summer I switched to AT&T because verizon's network was dropping my calls in my apartment half the time or more. And this is just 2 miles outside of downtown Portland, Or. Haven't had a dropped call on my iPhone on AT&T yet.

So just remember that strength of network is not "national", because most people don't move around all the time. Find the network that is best in your area first, then pick a phone.