Re:Yes, ask the people! (Score 1)

It's not the same thing at all. I was not suggesting that Blair ask the people if they want an ID card. I am suggesting he say, "You are having an ID card, what would you like to see from such a system?"

For example, the recent fiasco over postal voting, and the inevitibility of online voting at some point in the future, could have prompted them to consider some form of digital certificate on the cards. I personally would be much more willing to accept them, if it meant I could replace some of the other cards I have to carry around. Why not have a small area for users to store information of their own choosing (on the card, not on the database). Such information could include; library number, video store number, student number, loyalty card numbers, and even e-cash.

I am not suggesting that the list above is finite or even appropriate, but surely giving the public things they see as useful would make the card more acceptable.

As to Blair risking things on the result of a vote, he has done it before, and I'm sure he will do it again, but you are right, and that is why I voted against Blair in the last election.