Bacteria Found On ISS May Be Alien In Origin, Says Cosmonaut (independent.co.uk) 240
Password Sharing Is a Federal Crime, Appeals Court Rules (vice.com) 165
Terahertz Radiation To Enable Portable Particle Accelerators (www.desy.de) 52
How Much Data Plan Bandwidth Is Wasted By DRM? 200
Comment Re:What a Surprise (Score 1) 57
Comment Note about Ekhad (Score 5, Interesting) 185
Rogue Satellite Shuts Down US Weather Services 202
Astonishing Speedup In Solving Linear SDD Systems 157
Comment Late night memories of youth (Score 1) 84
Comment Re:Book reviews? (Score 1) 531
The answers to your questions depend on what you think is the purpose of a published book review.
In my discipline (mathematics), reviews of research monographs that appear in journals usually have an opening paragraph describing the book under review and a couple of closing paragraphs summarizing the contents of the book, judging the quality of the book, and sometimes listing the errors found by the reviewer. In between those paragraphs are pages and pages in which the reviewer usually gives his or her personal view of the subject of the book. That is, book reviews are seen as excuses for a reviewer to write exposition about a subject he or she enjoys. I think it's a little strange, and rarely interesting, but that's the norm.
I agree with the sentiment I once read that it's a waste of time to review a bad book, especially a mediocre one. A book review should, in my opinion, either steer the reader towards a book worth reading, explaining why the book is worthy and important; or, in cases of books published with a lot of fanfare (e.g., Wolfram's A New Kind of Science), discuss the merits or lack thereof of a book of which the reader is already aware. Why waste the time of reviewers and readers trashing a book no one will hear of otherwise? Just let such books die deservedly in obscurity.
A notable exception is an entertaining review of a truly wretched book. That's fun to read, but only if the reviewer is sufficiently talented to pull it off.
Behind Google's Recent Decision About China 155
Microsoft Patches "Google Hack" Flaw In IE 142
Haskell 2010 Announced 173