Comment The Three Rules I Try to Follow (Score 1) 275
My perspective may stem from timing - most of the recent ugliness and arguing online over recent events started around the same time I returned to school, so I was relearning to argue at the same time I was learning to site sources for college papers. That being said, it made it easier to weed some of the truth, as well as shape said perspective.
- Any source using a clip, video or audio, must include enough context to fully stand by, or must have an unedited source that can be easily found. An example of this is the famous clip Democrats repeatedly used of Donald Trump's mocking of the handicapped journalist - especially when Republican groups started trying to erase it.
- If there's no common clip/source, news must be able to be found from three similar, but truly different, sources. These sources must say something similar enough in actions, while not word-for-word outside of the quotes - two places can't use the Associated Press as their source, for example, or it's counted the same. This was a common thing I've noticed with conservative sites - they may change two or three sentences, or add a few paragraphs (usually an opinion or criticism), but otherwise it'd be the exact same thing, as if it was copied-and-pasted.
- If the first source comes from an opinion, that opinion must site sources in a similar fashion. (Anyone can write blogs - such as I did before the election on a similar subject: https://w2ed.wordpress.com/2016/08/29/the-resources-i-follow-for-political-information )
While it's not a perfect system - it doesn't weed out anything leaning towards a particular slant - it does verify that something is legitimately true. It's too easy to get wrapped in something that's a lie - and with everyone want to steer you in their circle, even something as simple as my system is still better than nothing. The trick isn't to rely on one news source - especially if you're worried abut the topic, or will argue about it. Instead, if you can't find the source or something unedited, treat it like your professor expecting your final paper.