Comment Expecting 18 year olds to write adult essays (Score 2) 128
I grew up working class and got zero help with my college applications, and it showed in my admission results as I was summarily rejected from all the top tier schools I applied to. This was decades ago now. Being an 18 year old, I remember writing edgy, perhaps even cringe-worthy, applications to try and stand out, when really admissions officers are looking for an unrealistically mature take on a prompt with a few dog whistles about my relationship with a social topic du jour. So yeah, I buy the premise that essays disadvantage people who can't afford to have their applications reviewed by experts.