Comment Oh no. Not the show worse than Rings of Power. (Score 3, Insightful) 101
Honestly, I'm shocked it got a second season. It was objectively worse than Rings of Power. Disagree? Here's why:
Both have almost nothing to do with the source material.
- RoP didn't get a license for the Silmarilian, the book that covers the period prior and closest to where they set the story. So it couldn't be good. They should have shelved the project at that point, but failing to climb a mountain with two broken legs doesn't make you a bad climber, just an idiot for trying.
- WoT on the other hand had a license to all the source material, full access to RJ's Widow/editor + his assistant + Brandon Sanderson who worked to finish the last three books, and chose to ignore the source material and the people most familiar to them and just to do their own thing. This was an unforced error.
The characters, their back stories, their behavior, and their values are wildly different than the books, essentially new characters wearing their names. Similar issues with the lore early on that are pretty core to the story - no idea how they intended to fix that if it had survived to later books, but I'm guessing since all the characters were essentially new, the ending would have been as well. Just one character and relationship example: Mat in the books is a fun loving, humorous rogue archetype, with a tendency to get himself into trouble, but a nack for getting back out of it. He has a loving family, and his father (Abell Cauthon) is known to be a shrewd horse trader, from whom Mat learned a lot about horses, how to watch out for scams, and to deal fairly but firmly. Abell along with Rand's father leave the Two Rivers shortly after the kids hoping to catch up and help look after them as they adapt to the wider world, though they never do catch the group. In the show? Abell is an abusive drunk. End of story.
It's not even internally consistent, killing a character at the end of the first season, realizing he was too important to the story to have dead and just having him walk onscreen in season 2 without comment. The whole world is wildly different too, with White Cloaks operating with impunity within the borders of Andor - something Morgase wouldn't have ever allowed in the books one example from the first episode). If they wanted to do an original fantasy show, they should have done that. Getting a license only to ignore everything that people value in the original work isn't going to do better than a new property after the first couple episodes, because the built in fanbase will be angry instead of excited.
Bottom line: it was bad, and Rafe should feel bad.