Re:This is Microsoft Excel's fault (Score 1)

It seems that there is probably some data confusion that it is not as simple as what Mann said, but what is boils down to is the 'audit' is embarassingly messed up. You can look at the two papers comments yourselves: Here is the E&E paper's website: http://www.climate2003.com And Mann's reply website: http://holocene.evsc.virginia.edu/Mann/EEReply.htm l It will be interesting to spot the anti-greenhouse propagandists, who don't report on their forthcoming paper which debunks the debunker. However, one can probably spot those already as lots of posters have mentioned - there are lots of other independent climate reconstructions, which generally agree with Mann et al rather than the E&E paper. However, you often sees anti-kyoto articles talking about how the stratosphere isn't warming (despite several years of papers showing that it actually it is!).