Comment Re:Differently-abled? (Score 1) 189
That's the whole point of health monitoring in an engine, a.k.a. man-rating the rocket.
Do you think the engine is chugging along nicely one moment and the next one it just goes BOOM?
I asked (as "Anonymous Coward"), several comments ago to point out one explosive liquid engine failure. If the troubled N-1 from over 40 years ago is the only example then I rest my case.
For comparison, I'll point out two recent rocket failures:
1) Sea Launch Zenit where debris caused the engine turbopump to fail, the rocket lost thrust, fell back to the pad immediately after liftoff and blew up. It was loss of thrust, not explosive engine failure that doomed the rocket.
2) Soyuz Foton-M launch. Immediately after liftoff, debris in one of the booster engines caused problems that were correctly picked up by the flight computer and the vehicle simply shut down all the engines (as part of the flight termination system). Still intact, it fell down to the pad resulting in a major explosion. Again, loss of thrust doomed the rocket, not explosive engine failure.
Do you think the engine is chugging along nicely one moment and the next one it just goes BOOM?
I asked (as "Anonymous Coward"), several comments ago to point out one explosive liquid engine failure. If the troubled N-1 from over 40 years ago is the only example then I rest my case.
For comparison, I'll point out two recent rocket failures:
1) Sea Launch Zenit where debris caused the engine turbopump to fail, the rocket lost thrust, fell back to the pad immediately after liftoff and blew up. It was loss of thrust, not explosive engine failure that doomed the rocket.
2) Soyuz Foton-M launch. Immediately after liftoff, debris in one of the booster engines caused problems that were correctly picked up by the flight computer and the vehicle simply shut down all the engines (as part of the flight termination system). Still intact, it fell down to the pad resulting in a major explosion. Again, loss of thrust doomed the rocket, not explosive engine failure.