Comment Re:To clear thing out (I hope) (Score 1) 582
Exactly the problem!
You are not going to say - that he is dead,right?
But you don't know if he is alive.
So
Exactly the problem!
You are not going to say - that he is dead,right?
But you don't know if he is alive.
So
Exactly!
Well,the _ donation _ is not a problem
When do you consider a person dead
This is _ not _ a simple question to ask.
The current knowledge in medicine says the moment of death is the "brain death".
However this is not so simple.
If there _ is _ a possibility of a person to be back alive after a "brain death" then taking his organs is
pratically killing him
This "moment of death" is the real Judaism problem .
While doctors say it is OK to take your organs
1. The person is _ really _ dead (when we think of a person as dead?)
2. Why would you trust _ any _ doctor on such a thing?
So
1. The moment of death is the brain death
there is a need of more then just one doctor to decide
that and one _ none _ doctor to see that the two other guys are not going to just kill somebody
for money.
There is a law in preparing actually in Isarel that makes all this to happen.
2. The moment of death is the moment of heart actually stopping.
This is _ against _ of current science
Note however that if an organ was _ already _ taken than the person is already dead anyway and thus
the "receiving an organ is OK under religious law".
Just trying to clear thing out.
Well,the _ donation _ is not a problem
When do you consider a person dead
This is _ not _ a simple question to ask.
The current knowledge in medicine says the moment of death is the "brain death".
However this is not so simple.
If there _ is _ a possibility of a person to be back alive after a "brain death" then taking his organs is
pratically killing him
This "moment of death" is the real Judaism problem .
While doctors say it is OK to take your organs
1. The person is _ really _ dead (when we think of a person as dead?)
2. Why would you trust _ any _ doctor on such a thing?
So
1. The moment of death is the brain death
there is a need of more then just one doctor to decide
that and one _ none _ doctor to see that the two other guys are not going to just kill somebody
for money.
There is a law in preparing actually in Isarel that makes all this to happen.
2. The moment of death is the moment of heart actually stopping.
This is _ against _ of current science
Note however that if an organ was _ already _ taken than the person is already dead anyway and thus
the "receiving an organ is OK under religious law".
Just trying to clear thing out.
"Religion is something left over from the infancy of our intelligence, it will fade away as we adopt reason and science as our guidelines." -- Bertrand Russell