Actually, once you take out the 50 odd muslim countries, most of the world's population has no views on Israel/Jews, one way or another. More often than not, Leftist parties in those countries tend to be anti-Israel, while Rightist parties in those countries tend to be either agnostic or pro-Israel. In the UN, you have a diplomatic club where everybody votes anti-Israel regardless of their own governments b'cos they want to keep getting invited to international cocktail parties in DC. Or b'cos their governments are bribed by countries like Qatar or Turkey to be hostile to Israel
"Once you remove all the inconvenient data points, and embrace the very specific bias that I have, you start to see things my way".
Reality matters. These fifty Muslim countries matter, I don't see why their opinion should be ignored. By the way, having no view on something is not supporting it. The regime in Iran before the Islamic revolution was supported by the CIA, and the Islamic revolution was initially a multipartite revolution that the Islamic fundamentalists appropriated. The population was fed up with the CIA-backed monarchy. Also I'm not sure why you mention "Jews", we were taking about Israel. If you equate Jewishness with Israel then you are just repeating propaganda. There's plenty of Jews all over the world that are critical of Israel - including in Israel.
I'll leave here a reference to this UN vote as an example that what you say is not supported by reality.