Comment Re:communications system? (Score 1) 149
I'd love to see these systems handle someone in the right turn lane with their signal on swooping over 3 lanes and turning left...
Sorry, but this is such a stupid argument. It is unfortunate that human drivers do stupid stuff like this. It is unfortunate that those around such stupidity have to get into accidents because of it. My thoughts on self driving cars is the following:
1) Human driven car A does a stupid manouver
2) Human driven car B tries but maybe fails to avoid, accident ensues.
Result: No one is at fault because everyone blames each other. Stupidity on the roads continues. Accidents continue to kill and harm people. Insurance rates continue to rise, etc. Status quo.
In the alternative world with some self driving cars:
1) Human driven car A does a stupid manouver
2) Computer driven car B tries to avoid, but fails, accident ensues.
Result: Recordings from onboard computers prove who was at fault (car A). Blame is delivered, just their insurance rates rise, and only their record is ruined. Hopefully they learn they're lesson and either (a) drive better or (b) get a car that'll drive for them. End result is that overall driving safety is improved.
The (safe) assumption with all of this is that a computer driven car would be recording data equivalent to an aircraft's black box (probably in much much more detail really). Use the data on that recording to figure out what happened, if a human driven car (car A) caused an accident that wasn't avoidable by the other car assuming a reasonable human driver then, car B deserves no blame (whether it was driven by human or computer). The recorded information allows you to recreate the accident and make a reasonable judgement as to the circumstances. The system (police, courts, insurance, society) can dish out blame and punishment on a much more reasonable basis then.
The dashboard cam craze is the same thing, it provides a recording so that you can prove you are driving reasonably and whatever happened was the result of someone else making a mistake. All of this is big-brother-ish, but if we all really are such good drivers (everyone thinks they are better than average), then feel free to be recorded so that your own recorded evidence can set you free.