Re:Neurofeedback and New Games (Score 1)

The learning effect of this kind of feedback for singing may have a lasting effect, but I doubt it. Studies on pronunciation for English as a Second Language (ESL) Learners show that instant feedback does not improve pronunciation for more than that instance. No generalization, which means that if they try to pronouce the same thing 10 minutes later without the software, in a new situation, there is no improvement. My guess is that this new effort will get similar results. Sorry to be so negative, but learning a new skill, one as basic as concentrating, needs more than just a quick feedback mechanism.