I'm siding with Rowling. (Score 1)

I can't help but side with Rowling in this. She has been very lenient with most fansites, even giving out awards for various ones - including the Lexicon. She was very supportive of it when it was a not-for-profit fansite, but now that he's trying to publish it and make money off of it, she says no. I can't blame her at all for that. From what I can gather from reports I've read, it's only a collection of facts from Rowling's books, and not a collection of critical commentary or essays about her work, so it really isn't fair use at all.