Comment Re:Disconnected from reality. (Score 3, Informative) 86
I don't like Anthropic's stock, I'm not buying any, but this just incorrect and should be corrected. I'm kind of surprised it's +5 on
The math mathing really isn't the problem at all. If Anthropic can grow as fast next year and the year after as they did over the previous year, the numbers check out just fine. This is a perfectly normal way to value all companies. It's just *wildly* more aggressive than normal. I don't know if any company has ever gone public with these numbers, but the numbers check out pretty much perfectly fine. It would just be normal for them to remain private at this stage, but virtually no company is so big at this stage, and so in need of cash.
The case for Anthropic's valuation is really pretty simple. I don't agree with it, but we can at least represent it correctly. Their $33 billion revenue is well over 10x what it was a year ago. If you believe they can repeat that growth this year, and the year after that, the $2 trillion is actually pretty cheap. They would be at around $700 billion in revenue in two years if they can do that, and those commitments aren't even that high at that point.
I'm not buying any, but it's not because the numbers don't work out, it's because I just really doubt they can possibly do that. AI prices will be a race to the bottom. If they *merely* triple their revenue next year, it should dive.
But really, importantly, if you simply believe that they can repeat what they've already done, the math is fine. And that's basically how all stocks work.
Critically though, their expenses *over that nine months* were not anywhere near in the hundreds of billions. This is wildly deceptive. I think you are confusing their expenses, with their long-term commitments. They have committed to ~$900 billion in future compute spending, that is true, and insane. It is part of why they *have* to see that crazy growth for this to work out, and why they need to go public when it normally wouldn't happen. But over that nine month period, it's less than $20 billion, somewhere around half the revenue. It arguably should have been higher, they were sort of getting some crazy discounts, but still, absolutely nowhere near it being the case that they spent hundreds of billions while making $33 billion.