The problem with that idea is who controls procreation. Who would you trust to decide you could give birth and who couldn't? There's a reason that Hitler used the idea and it has a great potential for abuse.
On a side note, there is legal precident for the right to give birth. During the contriversy in the 70's over "test tube babies/artificial insemination", it was determined that US citizens do have reproductive rights. I'm sure there's tons of other cases involving the concept. Maybe by fundamental, you weren't talking US law? I can follow the argument half way, but when it comes to deciding for other people...it just doesn't sit well.