I make games for a living, and have tried many of the gamification apps for things like household chores or which beers you've drank to see what they're like. They're a pain in the butt to enter things into and just aren't much fun IMO.
What you're saying can be summarized as "this is hard so it isn't worth doing".
This is what passes for insightful commentary on Slashdot today?
I know, I know, I must be new here.
I'm sorry that's what you gathered from my post. It's not what I wrote or intended anyone to take away.
A better summary: Layering a game like structure on top of everyday activities has so far not produced many good experiences. Unless there are major unforeseeable advances in experience design and technology over the next couple of years, there will not be anywhere close to 85% of daily activities structured as "games".
I make games for a living, and have tried many of the gamification apps for things like household chores or which beers you've drank to see what they're like. They're a pain in the butt to enter things into and just aren't much fun IMO.
I've seen some interesting things in education, where achievement and point systems are used to construct a less bad grading system, which is cool. But to get to 85% of daily tasks being gamified would take a ton of amazing experience design and technological advancements that I just don't see happening by 2020. Maybe more like 5% would be a more reasonable estimate.
Also, if my HR department decides to gamify performance reviews I'm going to lose it.
Not to be all conspiratorial, but I think it's been a while now since politicians were really in charge of this sort of thing.
Agreed. I would add, I doubt that anyone who's done the things you have to do to get elected at the national level wants to cross the folks that have access to potentially EVERY electronic piece of information generated by them, their family and staff in the last decade plus. Don't think for a minute that if someone like Feinstein got critical of their programs, some shady business dealings of her husband's or his associates wouldn't get laundered to FBI or others.
When your work speaks for itself, don't interrupt. -- Henry J. Kaiser